Showing posts with label Rule 43(b) (a)(ii). Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rule 43(b) (a)(ii). Show all posts

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Patna High Court exonerates Dr. Vinod Kumar Singh, Professor of Nephrology in PILs by Vikash Chandra Guddu Baba, Bihar Health Department's proceeding "bad in law, hence are quashed"

In Dr. Vinod Kumar Singh vs. The State of Bihar, through the Principal Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar & Ors. (2026), Patna High Court's Division Bench of Justices Mohit Kumar Shah and Sourendra Pandey delivered 1 32-page long judgement dated November 18, 2026, wherein, it concluded: "19....we find that the resolution dated 17.08.2015, issued under the pen and signature of the Additional Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, Patna by which the departmental proceeding was initiated against the appellant under Rule 17 of the Rules, 2005 and the amended resolution issued by the Joint Secretary to the Government, Health Department, Government of Bihar, Patna contained in Memo dated 30.06.2021, converting the pending departmental proceeding into one under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950 are bad in law, hence are quashed. Consequently, the order dated 02.03.2023, passed by the learned Single Judge in CWJC No.381 of 2023 is set aside. 20. In the result, the appeal stands allowed."

In the penultimate paragraph, it observed: "17. We find from the language used in Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950 that the same is absolutely clear and there is no scope for the Court to innovate or take upon the task of amending or altering the statutory provisions in absence of there being any ambiguity, thus we are of the view that the Single Judge has, in the impugned order dated 02.03.2023 erroneously held that the State cannot be precluded from proceeding ahead under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950 against the appellant on account of the orders passed by the learned Division Bench of this Court in the aforesaid PIL, since the same would be against the spirit of the orders of the learned Division Bench. In this regard, it would suffice to state that in none of the orders passed by the learned Division Bench of this Court in the aforesaid PIL, any direction has been issued to act contrary to the prevailing law apart from the fact that said PIL has stood dismissed long time back by an order dated 04.01.2012. In any view of the matter, the orders dt. 06.12.2010, 01.04.2011 and 03.2.2011 passed by the learned Division Bench of this Court in the aforesaid PIL, referred to by the learned Single Judge in the impugned order dated 02.03.2023, pertains to taking administrative action as also criminal action against the concerned person/officer/staff immediately, however till the date of retirement of the appellant i.e. 31.05.2015, even after lapse of about four and a half years of passing of the first order dated 06.12.2010 by the learned Division Bench of this Court, no departmental proceeding was initiated against the appellant, however only after his retirement, a departmental proceeding was initiated on 17.08.2015, that too under a wrong provision of law i.e. under Rule 17 of the Rules, 2005 which was/is illegal and bad in law inasmuch as on account of cessation of master servant relationship, the Rules, 2005 had become inapplicable to the appellant." 

It added: "Moreover, the conversion of the departmental proceeding initiated against the appellant under the Rules, 2005 into one under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950, vide resolution contained in Memo dated 30.06.2021 is also illegal inasmuch as no departmental proceeding could have been initiated against the appellant in respect of a misconduct which took place more than four years before the initiation of such proceeding, particularly considering the fact that in the present case the alleged misconduct pertains to the financial years 2008-09 and 2009-10. Thus, we find that the Ld. Single Judge could neither have expanded the scope of Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950 nor could have on the pretext of the orders of the Hon’ble Division Bench passed in the aforesaid PIL opined that any interference by the Court with the proceeding under the Pension Rules would be against the spirit of the said orders passed by the learned Division Bench, especially since the said PIL bearing CWJC No.16856 of 2010 had stood dismissed on 04.01.2012. departmental inquiry which was held qua the appellant was in pursuance to an illegally initiated departmental proceeding by the respondents vide resolution dated 17.08.2015 and the same had culminated into submission of an inquiry report dated 29.07.2020 by the Additional Secretary, Health Department, Bihar, Patna, even prior to conversion of the said proceeding into one under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950 vide amended resolution dated 30.06.2021, hence the entire inquiry proceedings including the inquiry report dated 29.07.2020 is on the very face of it per se illegal, thus the same has also got no legs to stand resulting in the second show cause notice dated 30.06.2021 being also bad in law."

The LPA was filed against the order dated March 2, 2023, passed by the Single Judge of the High Court in whereby and whereunder the writ petition filed by the appellant was dismissed. The appellant, being a Senior Doctor at the Patna Medical College and Hospital, Patna (PMCH) was appointed as the Head of the Department, Nephrology. In the meantime, a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) was filed by one Vikash Chandra Guddu Baba bearing CWJC No.16856 of 2010, inter alia alleging therein that there was misappropriation of the funds allotted to PMCH, Patna in purchase of medicines etc. and in the financial year 2009-10 substantial irregularities have been committed by various Departments of PMCH in asmuch as those medicines which were purchased in the financial year 2008-09 at a reasonable rate and in reasonable quantity have been purchased in the next financial year at a much higher rate and in huge quantity resulting in the medicines purchased in the year 2009-10 remaining unutilized. A Division Bench of the High Court, by an order dated December 6, 2010, passed in the said PIL, had directed the Principal Secretary to take appropriate action with the help of Vigilance Department resulting in show cause notice dated January 6, 2011 being issued to the appellant by the Joint Secretary, Health Department, i.e. the respondent no.3, alleging therein that during the financial year 2009-10, irregularities were committed in purchase of medicines, reagents, consumables and disposable items resulting in financial loss to the Government as also the kits purchased for the Nephrology Department were purchased without obtaining the MRP of the kit or comparing the prices with the price of the said kit in the year 2008-09 and order was placed by the department head and the hospital administration for the kit without ascertaining its actual requirement. 

The appellant had filed a reply dated January 19, 2011 clarifying the entire aspect of the matter and denying the allegation levelled against him.  The PIL bearing CWJC No.16856 of 2010 was dismissed by the Division Bench of this Court vide order dated January 4, 2012 with an observation that as the matter is under supervision of Vigilance Department, the Principal Secretary, Department of Health, Medical Education and Family Welfare, Government of Bihar, Patna is directed to dispose of the representations filed by the petitioner of the said writ petition in accordance with law. The Vigilance Department had then filed an FIR bearing Patna Vigilance Case No.061/2013 dated September 25, 2013 wherein, the appellant was named as one of the accused persons merely since he was a member of the Purchase Committee on account of being the Head of the Nephrology Department. 

It was the case of the appellant that the Superintendent of Police-cum-Investigator, Vigilance Investigation Bureau vide letter dated October 9, 2013 had sought for a clarification from him regarding the financial irregularities in purchase of medicines, reagents, machines and equipments at PMCH during the financial years 2008-09 and 2009-10 to which he had submitted his reply and denied his role, vide letter dated October 22, .2013, however without conducting proper investigation and without considering the detailed reply filed by the appellant, the Vigilance Department had obtained sanction for prosecution vide order contained in Memo dated May 22, 2014 and the said vigilance case was still pending at the evidence stage. In fact, one another PIL bearing CWJC No.10303 of 2013 was also filed by Vikash Chandra Guddu Baba, however the same had also stood disposed of vide order dated September 11, 2014.

The appellant had retired from service on May 31, 2015 while working on the post of Professor Nephrology, Jawaharlal Nehru Medical College Hospital, Bhagalpur, whereafter departmental proceeding was initiated against him under Rule 17 of the Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 2005 vide Memo dated August 17, 2015 and the Joint Secretary Health Department was appointed as Inquiry Officer while the Principal, PMCH was appointed as the Presenting Officer as also charge-sheet in Prapatra-‘Ka’ & list of evidence was provided to the appellant to file his reply to the same. The allegations levelled in the aforesaid charge sheet, issued to the appellant are that during the financial years 2008-09 and 2009-10, irregularities were committed in purchase of medicines, reagents, machines and equipment’s at PMCH, Patna for which investigation was carried out by the Vigilance Investigation Bureau, whereupon it has transpired that in collusion with the supplier, items have been purchased above the MRP, machines have been purchase at a rate much higher than the rate of the manufacturer, items have been purchased without ascertaining the actual requirement and much more than the required quantity resulting in misappropriation of government funds to the tune of Rs. 12,63,62,970/-.

The appellant had then, vide letter dated August 12, 2015 requested the Inquiry Officer to provide certain documents for enabling him to file a detailed reply to the charge memo, however the said documents were not provided to him and the Inquiry Officer continued with the departmental proceeding. In fact, the list of witnesses was also not provided along with the charge memo. Thereafter, the appellant vide letter dated September 22, 2017, once again requested the Inquiry Officer to provide certain documents for enabling him to file a detailed reply and for properly representing his case, however despite several requests and reminders, the respondent authorities failed to provide the copies of evidence to the appellant, as a result he was constrained to file his reply vide letter dated December 3, 2018 without availability of the essential documents sought for by him. In the said reply, the appellant stated as follows:-
a. For the purpose of procuring medicines, reagents, equipments etc., notice of tender is issued in newspaper by the Superintendent, PMCH.

b. The Superintendent, PMCH is the President of the Purchase Committee.

c. The lowest rate is declared from the technically qualified tenders.

d. The role of the department head is to grant approval on the basis of the technical distinctiveness.

c. The bill is paid under the signature of the Superintendent, PMCH.

e. All 66 charges imposed upon the appellant regarding irregularities in purchase of equipments are baseless. 

f. Purchase clerk, head clerk and accountant are responsible for carrying out the department orders in relation to finance.

g. As per the guidelines issued by the Health Department, for any irregularity/shortcoming with respect to procedure of purchase only the Superintendent, PMCH is liable.

h. Even as per the letter dated September 5, 2013 issued by the Directorate Drug Control Administration, the appellant cannot be held responsible.

i. There is no allegation upon the appellant that despite the equipments, reagents etc. being of sub-standard quality, approval was granted by the appellant.

The appellant had therefore, in his reply dated December 3, 2018, prayed before the Inquiry Officer to exonerate him from the charges. 

In the meanwhile, the appellant had sought for certain information from the PMCH under the Right to Information Act, 2005, in response whereof he had received information on January 6, 2016 from which it was evident that the Superintendent, PMCH was responsible for approving the purchase list and no other person has the authority to approve the same. Moreover, only with regard to the requirement of medicine, the head of the department was consulted and the inventory officer was responsible to provide a list of requirements of medicines on the basis of consumption of the medicines. It was also the case of the appellant that without considering the requests of the appellant for grant of copies of essential documents, the Additional Secretary, Health Depart., in his inquiry report contained in Memo No.145 dated July 29, 2020, found the appellant guilty of charges specified under the Charge Memo. 

The appellant being aggrieved by the aforesaid resolution dated August 17, 2015, initiating departmental proceeding against him as also by the resolution contained in Memo dated June 30, 2021, issued by the Joint Secretary, Health Department whereby and whereunder the departmental proceeding initiated against the appellant under Rule 17 of the Rules, 2005 was belatedly converted to one under Rule 43(b) of Rules, 1950 had preferred a writ petition bearing CWJC No.381 of 2023, inter alia praying therein for quashing the aforesaid two resolutions dated August 17, 2015 and June 30, 2021 as also for quashing the entire departmental proceedings initiated against him, however the said writ petition has stood dismissed by an order dated March 2, 2023, passed by the Single Judge of the High Court.

With regard to the inquiry report dated July 29, 2020, the appellant's counsel submitted that that there was no iota of evidence against the appellant and the inquiry officer held the appellant guilty merely on the basis of the fact that the Vigilance Department in its letter, which forms basis of the institution of Vigilance Case No. 61/2013 against the appellant and others, found prima facie case against the appellant. 

The appellant retired on May 31, 2015, however the departmental proceeding was wrongly initiated on August 17, 2015 under Rule 17 of the Rules, 2005 and in order to rectify the defect committed in initiation of the proceedings, the Joint Secretary, Health Department vide Memo dated June 30, 2021, belatedly converted the departmental proceeding to one under Rule 43(b) of the Bihar Pension Rules, 1950, whereafter on June 30, 2021 itself, a second show cause notice was issued to the appellant. In response to the said second show cause notice, the appellant filed his reply dated September 8, 2021, raising preliminary objection to the effect that in view of Rule 43(b)(a) (ii) of the Rules, 1950, departmental proceeding cannot be initiated against a retired employee in respect of an incident which had occurred more than four years before the institution of such proceedings, hence the action of the respondent authorities is baseless and without any legal force.

The Single Judge failed to appreciate that after the retirement of the appellant on May 31, 2015, departmental proceedings could not have been initiated under Rules, 2005 since the same is applicable only in the case of a serving employee, hence the order contained in Memo dated August 17, 2015 was not only illegal but also bad in law, hence was fit to be set aside. In fact, the Single Judge failed to consider that since the master servant relationship in between the appellant and the respondents came to an end on the date of his superannuation i.e. on May 31, 2015, no proceeding could have been initiated against the appellant under Rule 17 of the Rules, 2005.

Advocate Dr. Gopal Krishna observed that in view of Rule 43(b)(a)(ii) of the Rules, 1950, a departmental proceeding cannot be initiated against a retired employee with respect of an incident which has occurred more than four years before the institution of such proceedings. 

In the case in question, the incident has taken place during the financial years 2008-09 and 2009-10. After passage of almost six years of retirement of the appellant as also upon wrongful initiation of the departmental proceeding under Rule 17 of the Rules, 2005, the respondent authorities cannot be permitted to take advantage simpliciter by issuance of a notice dated June 30, 2021, converting the said departmental proceeding to one under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950. 

In State of Bihar vs. Mohd. Idris Ansari, reported in 1995 Supp (3) SCC 56, Supreme Court has been held that a departmental proceeding under Rule 43(b) of the Rules,1950 has to be in respect of misconduct, which took place not more than 4 years before the initiation of such proceedings. 

The judgment rendered by the Division Bench of the High Court in Urmila Singh @ Urmila Sharma vs. The State of Bihar and Ors., reported in 2010 (3) PLJR 845, was erroneously interpreted by the Single Judge, wherein, it was explicitly held that although during the time the employee and employer relationship existed there was no finding in any disciplinary proceeding or judicial proceedings that the employee concerned has caused pecuniary loss to the employer by his misconduct or negligence inasmuch
as no proceeding was initiated to ascertain the same during the time the employee had not superannuated by issuing a charge sheet, still such a proceeding can be initiated by issuing a charge sheet after superannuation and upon conclusion thereof punishment by way of reduction of pension in full or in part may be awarded
, however there is a time limit of four years to initiate such proceeding from the date of the 'event'. Moreover, the Division Bench has held that it is the date of the event which has to be considered and the concept of knowledge of the event is impliedly ousted.

Earlier, in Dr. Vinod Kumar Singh vs. The State of Bihar, through the Principal Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar & Ors. (2023) Justice Rajeev Ranjan Prasad, the Singe Judge  had delivered a 23-page long judgement dated March 2, 2023, wherein, he had concluded:" 34. This Court is, therefore, of the considered opinion that in this case the petitioner cannot be allowed to take advantage of the period spent by the competent authority in taking final decision to proceed against the petitioner under the Pension Rules. The delay on the part of competent authority in initiating appropriate action despite orders of the Hon’ble Division Bench cannot be cited as a valid impediment in the matter of conducting proceeding under the Pension Rules. The State would, thus, not be precluded from proceeding ahead under Rule 43(b) of the Rules. Any interference by this Court with the proceeding under the Pension Rules would be against the spirit of the orders of the Hon’ble Division Bench in the aforementioned PIL has no merit. It is dismissed, accordingly. 36. Let a copy of this order be communicated to the Principal Secretary/Additional Chief Secretary, Department of Health, Government of Bihar for necessary action." 

The petitioner had approached the Single Judge bench for issuance of an appropriate writ/order/direction in the nature of Certiorari thereby quashing Memo No 358(9) dated June 30, 2021 issued by the Joint Secretary, Health Department whereby and whereunder the departmental proceeding initiated against the Petitioner under Rules 17 of the Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 2005 has been belatedly converted under Rule 43B of the Bihar Pension Rules. He had also prayed for issuance of an appropriate writ/order/direction in the nature of Certiorari thereby quashing the entire departmental proceeding initiated against the Petitioner including the charge memo (papatra ‘ka’) issued vide Memo No. 728(9) dated August 17, 2015 as the same is in violation of the Rule 17 of the Bihar Government Servants (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 2005 as also Rule 43B of the Bihar Pension Rules.

Dr. Krishna observed that the provision of the statute has to be read as a whole and the Court cannot supplant its view and read into the statute to give it a meaning which is not the intent of the legislature. The Single Judge wrongly opined that the appellant cannot be allowed to take advantage of the period spent by the competent authority in taking final decision to proceed against the appellant under Rules, 1950 and the State cannot be precluded from proceeding ahead under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950 in view of the orders of the Division Bench in the aforementioned PIL, since any interference by the Court with the proceeding under the Pension Rule would be against the spirit of the order of the Division Bench in the said PIL. The Rule 43(b)(a)(ii) of the Rules, 1950 postulates that the statutory period for commencement of proceeding is within four years of the date on which the misconduct was committed in the case of a retired employee, thus the departmental proceeding which was initiated against the appellant under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950 after six years of his retirement, i.e. on May 31, 2015, by an order dated June 30, 2021, pertaining to an occurrence of alleged misconduct of the financial years 2008-09 and 2009-10 is clearly not permissible under Rule 43(b)(a)(ii) of the Rules, 1950, therefore, the Single Judge committed a grave error in not quashing the resolution dated June 30, 2021 as also the resolution dated August 17, 2015 by which a departmental proceeding was initiated against the appellant under Rules, 2005 which is not applicable in the case of a retired employee like the appellant, thus the order dated March 2, 2023, passed by the Single Judge has rightly been set aside by the Division Bench.

The Division Bench observed:"....we find that the facts of the present case lie in a narrow encompass inasmuch as on account of commission of alleged financial irregularities in the financial years 2008-09 and 2009-10, in purchase of medicines, reagents, machines, equipment’s etc. at a rate higher than the MRP and in huge quantity which caused grave financial loss to the State Government, a departmental proceeding was initiated against the appellant (after his retirement) vide resolution dt. 17.08.2015, issued under the pen and signature of the Additional Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, Patna under Rule 17 of the Rules, 2005. It appears that upon realizing the fact that no departmental proceeding could have been initiated against a retired employee under the Rules, 2005, the Joint Secretary to the Government, Health Department, Govt. of Bihar, Patna vide amended resolution contained in Memo dt.30.06.2021 had converted the pending departmental proceeding to one under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950, whereafter inquiry had taken place. It appears that prior to conversion of the departmental proceeding initiated against the appellant under the Rules, 2005 into one under Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950, the Additional Secretary, Health Department, Bihar, Patna had already submitted his inquiry report dt. 29.07.2020, finding the charges to have been proved qua the appellant. The Joint Secretary to the Government, Health Department, Govt. of Bihar, Patna vide letter dt. 30.06.2021 had then issued a second show cause notice to the appellant which was replied to by the appellant on 8.9.2021 raising a preliminary issue regarding maintainability of the departmental proceeding. The appellant had then challenged the aforesaid two resolutions dated 17.08.2015 and 30.06.2021 by filing a writ petition bearing CWJC No.381 of 2023 as also praying therein for quashing of the entire departmental proceeding initiated against him, however the same was dismissed by the Ld. Single Judge by an order dated 02.03.2023."

The Division Bench observed: "16. We find that the issues which arise for consideration in the present appeal is as to whether a different interpretation can be given to the word “event” and whether the bar of four years can be relaxed for initiating a departmental proceeding against a retired employee under proviso (ii) of Rule 43(b)(a) of the Rules, 1950 for justifying the continuance of a departmental proceeding against the appellant. At this juncture, it would be relevant to refer to Rule 43(b) of the Rules, 1950. A bare perusal of Rule 43(b)(a)(ii) of the Rules, 1950 would show that a departmental proceeding can be instituted after superannuation of a government servant not only after sanction of the State Government but also in respect of an event which took place not more than four years before the institution of such proceedings. The law in this regard is no longer res integra as has been held unequivocally by the learned Division Bench of this Court in the case of Urmila Sharma @ Urmila Singh that the aforesaid rule is very clear and there is no obscurity much less any ambiguity inasmuch as the rule has a purpose, i..e. to protect a government employee after his superannuation and though the power under Rule 43(b) can be exercised in connection with the alleged misconduct, however the same is subject to the rider that such departmental proceeding has to be in respect of a misconduct which took place not more than four years before the initiation of such proceeding." 

In fact, this aspect of the matter has also been conclusively decided in paragraph nos. 7 to 10 of the decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Mohd. Idris Ansari.