Sunday, November 22, 2026

Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha sets aside cognizance order by Brij Kishore Singh, Judicial Magistrate, Ist Class, Darbhanga, prosecution was initiated after 6 years of alleged occurrence

In Shyam Deo Thakur @ Dahaur Thakur & Ors. vs. The State of Bihar & Anr. (2026), Justice Chandra Shekhar Jha delivered a 6-page long judgment dated November 18, 2026 concluded:"10. Despite service of notice, none appeared on behalf of O.P. No.2....as the complaint was lodged against these petitioners after six years of alleged occurrence, where the investigation also continued for 5 years, wherein at first instance, police after investigation submitted final form against these petitioners. 12. Accordingly, in view of legal ratio of Robert Lalchungnunga Chongthu Case (supra) and Bhajan Lal Case (supra), the impugned cognizance order dated 02.02.2015 with all its consequential proceedings qua all above-named four petitioners are hereby set aside/quashed. 13. The present petition stands allowed. 14. Let the copy of this judgment be communicated to the learned trial court forthwith, with TCR, if any." The Opposite Party (O.P.) No. is Indu Devi. The four petitioners are: Shyam Deo Thakur @ Dahaur Thakur, Shailendra Kumar Thakur @ Salit Kumar Thakur @ Lalit Kumar Thakur, Meena Devi and Alindra Kumar Thakur @ Alindra Thakur, the residents of village- Sirhulli, Kamtaul, Darbhanga. 

The judgement was passed upon hearing an application for quashing the impugned order dated February 2, 2015 passed by Brij Kishore Singh,Judicial Magistrate, Ist Class, Darbhanga in Kamtaul P.S. Case No. 114/2010 (G.R. No. 2148/2010), whereby and whereunder the trial court has taken cognizance against the petitioners under Section 364 of the I.P.C. 

The fact of the application was that Indu Devi, the opposite party no.2 had filed a complaint petition before learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Darbhanga on June 21, 2010 bearing complaint case no. 1215/2010 alleging inter alia that the accused persons were her co-parceners. The accused persons used to assault her husband occasionally with a view to usurp his share in the property. It was alleged that in the month of April and May 2004, the accused persons assaulted her husband for 4-5 days, and at that time Alindra Kumar Thakur @ Alindra Thakur, the petitioner no.4 in collusion with other accused persons dragged her husband in the night of April and May 2004, assaulted him and her husband did not return home. It was alleged that on enquiry from the accused persons, they say that they do not know anything about him, and sometime they say that he was doing his job and would come home after sometime. The informant alleged that she had visited the police station many times for registering the case but she was unsuccessful. The police personal used to say the informant that a long time had passed, so she may approach the Court for registering the case. The informant suspected that with a view to grab the property of her husband and with an ill motive, the accused person killed her husband and disappeared his dead body. 4. After filing of the written complaint by the opposite party no.2, on June 21, 2010 itself the office of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Darbhanga, forwarded the same to O/C Kamtaul P.S. for institution and investigation of the case under Section 156(3) of Cr. P.C. 

After receiving the complaint from the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Darbhanga, Kamtaul Police registered a formal F.I.R. bearing Kamtaul P.S. Case No. 114/2010 on July 7, 2010 under Sections 364 and 365 of I.P.C. and after investigation submitted closure report against petitioners. 

In this context, it was pointed out by the counsel appearing for the petitioners that O.P. No. 2 filed a protest petition before the trial court on December 22, 2010, but was not taken on record as same was not pressed, but in meantime, the investigating officer filed an application before the trial court for further investigation of this case under Section 173(8) of the Cr.PC on February 17, 2012 which was allowed vide order dated February 17, 2012 itself and the matter was re-investigated pursuant to which the charge-sheet was submitted against petitioners followed by the cognizance of jurisdictional magistrate. 

The counsel for the petitioners submitted that the alleged occurrence took place in the month of April/May, 2004 without disclosing any particular date despite the complainant claimed herself as an eye-witness of the occurrence, as she witnessed that her husband was assaulted continuously for 4-5 days by these petitioners, and thereafter he disappeared. It was submitted that for the allegation, and occurrence which is alleged to be taken place in the month of April/May, 2004, the complaint was filed in year 2010 only i.e., after passing of 6 years. The complaint was sent to the police for investigation by the C.J.M. exercising power under Section 156(3) of the Cr.PC, wherein the police after investigation submitted the final form/closure report against these petitioners, but only after further investigation, the charge-sheet was submitted against these petitioners through supplementary charge-sheet dated August 31, 2014. The initiation of prosecution after 6 years of the alleged occurrence particularly when the complainant claimed herself as an eye-witness of the occurrence, and further thereafter, the continuation of investigation for long 5 years were sufficient grounds to quash the proceeding against these petitioners, which was completely unfounded and just to settle the personal vengeance as to grab the land of these petitioners. 

The counsel relied upon the legal report of Supreme Court in Robert Lalchungnunga Chongthu vs. State of Bihar reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2511 and State of Haryana & Ors. vs. Bhajan Lal & Ors. reported in 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335.

In the case of Robert Lalchungnunga Chongthu, Supreme Court's Division Bench of Justices Sanjay Karol and N. K. Singh had delivered a 46-page long judgement dated November 20, 2025, wherein, it issued the
following directions:
(i) In view of para 49 of the decision in Vinay Tyagi vs. Irshad Ali (2013) 5 SCC 762, it can be seen that the ‘leave of the court’ to file a supplementary chargesheet, is a part of Section 173(8) CrPC. That being the position, in our considered view, the Court is not rendered functus officio having granted such permission. Since the further investigation is being made with the leave of the Court, judicial stewardship/control thereof, is a function which the court must perform.
(ii) Reasons are indispensable to the proper functioning of the machinery of criminal law. They form the bedrock of fairness, transparency, and accountability in the justice system. If the Court finds or the accused alleges (obviously with proof and reason to substantiate the allegation) that there is a large gap between the first information report and the culminating chargesheet, it is bound to seek an explanation from the investigating agency and satisfy itself to the propriety of the explanation so furnished. The direction above does not come based on this case alone. This Court has noticed on many unfortunate occasions that there is massive delay in filing chargesheet/taking cognizance etc. This Court has time and again, in its pronouncements underscored the necessity of speedy investigation and trial as being important for the accused, victim and the society. However, for a variety of reasons there is still a lag in the translation of this recognition into a reality.
(iii) While it is well acknowledged and recognised that the process of investigation has many moving parts and is therefore impractical to have strict timelines in place, at the same time, the discussion made in the earlier part of this judgement, clearly establishes that investigations cannot continue endlessly. The accused is not out of place to expect, after a certain point in time, certainty- about the charges against him, giving him ample time to preparing plead his defence. If investigation into a particular offence has continued for a period that appears to be unduly long, that too without adequate justification, such as in this case, the accused or the complainant both, shall be at liberty to approach the High Court under Section 528 BNSS/482 CrPC, seeking an update on the investigation or, if the doors of the High Court have been knocked by the accused, quashing. It is clarified that delay in completion of investigation will only function as one of the grounds, and the Court, if in its wisdom, decides to entertain this application, other grounds will also have to be considered. 
(iv) Reasons are not only important in the judicial sphere, but they are equally essential in administrative matters particularly in matters such as sanction for they open the gateway to greater consequences. Application of mind by the authorities granting or denying sanction must be easily visible including consideration of the evidence placed before it in arriving at the conclusion."


No comments: