Monday, June 22, 2015

Dalit brothers, who cracked IIT, were tormented for their caste.Dalits Media Watch-News Updates 22.06.15

Dalits Media Watch

News Updates 22.06.15

Dalit brothers, who cracked IIT, were tormented for their caste- Deccan Herald

Dalit youth killed in police custody in Jammu- Kashmir Media Service

Police Nab Rape Accused in 24 Hours- The New Indian Express

Honour Killing: Youth slits sister's throat as parents, siblings keep guard, seven arrested - The Indian Express

Ringing with hate- Frontline

Please Watch :

Probe ordered into Lower Caste (Hindu) Dalit killings


Note: Please find attachment for DMW Hindi (PDF)

Deccan Herald

Dalit brothers, who cracked IIT, were tormented for their caste


The ordeals faced by the two dalit brothers, Brijesh and Raju, who cracked the IIT, throws light on the evils of caste based discrimination in our country. 

The two dalit boys might have set an example for many youngsters by cracking the IIT entrance test, but when they returned home victorious, stones were pelted at their house just because they belonged to a backward caste.

Revealing how they had struggled to study, the boys told Times Of India that people used to make fun of them when they expressed a desire for education.


The villagers discouraged them and tormented them when they joined school.

The lanes around their houses were blocked and even the drainage pipe of their house was cut off to punish them for pursuing education.

However, after they cracked the IIT, the villagers seem to have become quite polite to them now.

Raju Saroj secured 167th rank and his elder brother Brijesh secured 410th rank at the IIT exams.

Though the boys are among the top 500, they don't have fees to pay for their course.

UP Chief Minister Akhilesh Yadav, Congress vice-president Rahul Gandhi and Sulabh, a voluntary organisation have stepped forward to bear the expenses of these dalit boys.


Kashmir Media Service


Jammu, June 22 (KMS): In occupied Kashmir, Indian police killed in custody reportedly a Dalit youth, Tarsem Lal, 24, in Jammu.


Tarsem Lal was killed by the Special Operations Group (SOG) of Indian police.


National Panthers Party Chief Patron, Professor Bhim Singh while denounced the killing in a statement demanded registration of FIR against police under section 302. He said that the Dalit youth was killed right in front of Damana Police Station.


The NPP chief described the killing as a terrorist act of the men in uniform and demanded entire reshuffle in the police. He urged Governor to declare emergency as the puppet regime had failed to protect the life and property of the people.


The New Indian Express

Police Nab Rape Accused in 24 Hours


MANGALURU: In a swift move, the district police on Sunday nabbed a 30-year-old man in connection with the alleged rape of a minor dalit girl at Paduva in Kadaba police station limits on Saturday.


The police arrested K Shekhar of Koila village in Puttur taluk within 24 hours of the incident.


Superintendent of Police S D Sharanappa told reporters that Shekhar was a daily wager who also worked as a part-time driver.


The 16-year-old girl is a ninth standard student in a local school.


She used to go to school with her sister, who works for a private firm at Uppinangady.


The incident took place when she was returning from school on Saturday.


After alighting from a jeep near Koila Farm, she was walking to her house.


When she reached Padavu, Shekhar dragged her from behind into an acacia grove where he allegedly raped and abandoned her.


Though traumatised, she managed to reach home and inform her parents. Her parents rushed to Kadaba police station and filed a complaint.


With clues such as the guy was dark complexioned and had a mobile phone with a red case, the police were able to launch a search operation with the help of locals.


When they nabbed Shekhar and interrogated him, he confessed to the crime. The victim also identified Shekhar.


The accused must have been following the victim for a few days and hatched a plan to rape her on Saturday as she was not accompanied by her sister, the Superintendent of Police added.


The Indian Express

Honour Killing: Youth slits sister's throat as parents, siblings keep guard, seven arrested


Written by Manish Sahu | Lucknow | Updated: June 22, 2015 2:12 am


In a suspected case of "honour killing", the police have arrested the parents, two brothers and two sisters of a 19-year-old Dalit girl whose body was found in an open field in Sujanganj police station area in Jaunpur on June 12. The victim is a native of neighbouring Pratapgarh district.


The police said the family, which had already fixed the girl's marriage with someone else, "decided to kill her when she refused to snap ties with a youth she was having an affair".


Claiming that all the six arrested members have confessed to the crime, Sujanganj SO K K Mishra said the girl's elder brother slit her throat with a sharp-edged weapon while others caught hold of her. After she died, they carried her body to the neighbouring Jaunpur district and dumped it in an open field.


The police have also arrested the Jaunpur resident with whom the girl was having an affair. The youth, a Dalit, works as a tailor. The spot where the body was recovered is around 300 meters from the victim's residence in a village in Pratapgarh. The girl's father works in Allahabad while both his sons are daily-wage labourers. On the intervening night of June 11 and June 12, the girl's mother and two sisters took her to an isolated place on the pretext of meeting someone where her father and the two brothers were already present. The elder brother then slit her throat with a sharp-edged weapon while others kept their hold on her, Mishra said. They then dumped the body another 100-odd metres from the spot. The body was discovered by villagers next morning who then informed the police. The accused brother later visited the spot and identified the body as that of her sister, and then filed an FIR against two unidentified persons for killing his sister at the Patti police station in Pratapgarh. Superintendent of Police, Jaunpur, Bharat Singh said investigations have revealed that on June 11, a few hours before the murder, the youth had met the victim and threatened that he would commit suicide if she did not call off her marriage that her family had fixed for her. The police said that when she returned home after convincing the youth "not to take any extreme step", a heated argument took place between her and the family members, following which the family decided to kill her. All seven persons were produced before the court which has sent them to judicial custody.



Ringing with hate


Cimes against Dalits are on the rise in Maharashtra. Among the root causes are land-grabbing and sheer rage of dominant castes against the "defiance" of the lower castes. By LYLA BAVADAM


CASTE tensions are simmering in Maharashtra, where in the past 12 months alone there have been seven caste-related murders. The seemingly low figure is significant because the seven people lost their lives only because of the lower social status ascribed to them by birth. And the State revels in calling itself progressive and modern. The murders were of a gruesome nature; it was as if some vengeance was being exacted.


Only some of these cases have been registered under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, though on the face of it there are adequate pointers to a caste angle to all of them. Analysis of National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) data for crimes against Scheduled Castes under the Prevention of Atrocities Act from 2001 to 2012 shows that Maharashtra had 3,210 reported cases of atrocities in this period. The State was ninth on the list, which Uttar Pradesh topped with 26,378 cases followed by Tamil Nadu with 10,845. Priyadarshi Telang of Manuski, an organisation that campaigns for social justice, says Maharashtra has an annual conviction rate of less than 3 per cent and thus holds the State "responsible for the increasing caste atrocities in Maharashtra". The latest case, the murder of a young Dalit man in Shirdi, highlights the growing trend of violence against Dalits in Maharashtra. On May 16, nursing student Sagar Shejwal was murdered and his body mutilated. The reason for this brutality was something as innocuous as his cell phone ringtone, "Kara kitihi halla, majboot Bhimacha killa" (Raise your voice all you want, Bhim's fort remains strong). It is a song of strength for Dalits, a rallying cry with its references to solidarity and community togetherness and the leadership of B.R. Ambedkar. The higher castes perceive it as defiance, especially if they nurture resentment towards Dalits. This is what seems to have happened in Shirdi.


Sagar had come home to Shirdi to attend a wedding. On May 16, he and two cousins went to a local beer bar. At some point, his phone rang and this apparently annoyed some men in the bar. Recounting the story later, his brother Akash said a man came up to Sagar and asked for his name. When he replied, he asked Sagar to switch off his phone. Sagar refused, saying it caused no one any problem. That innocuous statement, combined with his obviously Dalit surname, was enough for the man and his eight friends to attack Sagar and his cousins with beer bottles. Akash said the bar owner called the police who apparently replied they had no vehicle to come to the site. Akash pointed out that that the police station was just two minutes' walk away.


As the fight turned more violent, Sagar got the worst of it. He was hit, kicked, punched, dragged out of the bar in a semi-conscious state, dumped onto a motorbike and taken away. His cousins alerted the rest of the family, but even a second appeal to the police station was turned down. The inspector apparently said, "He was just hit with a few bottles, wasn't he? He will be back in the evening." Unsatisfied with this, the boys gathered their friends and mounted a search. "We knew the general direction in which the bike had gone and kept asking people," said Akash, "and we finally found his body in a jungle."


Significantly, the fight was captured by the bar's security camera. This played a big part in the six arrests that have taken place so far. But what happened outside the shop was far worse and for this there are no witnesses. Once he was dumped on the bike, Sagar was taken to a wooded area, where his body was later found stripped of clothes and with multiple fractures and telltale marks of a two-wheeler having been driven over him. The autopsy report said he died of multiple fractures. The six men have been booked, among other things, for murder and offences under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. Sagar's assailants belong to the Maratha caste and Other Backward Classes (OBC).


The other six murders too highlight some commonalities. All of them were caste-specific. In all the reported cases, the aggressors were either from the Maratha community or from the OBCs, people belonging to communities just one level higher than Dalits in the caste hierarchy. Explaining this surprising lack of empathy for their kindred folk, Paul Divakar of the National Campaign on Dalit Human Rights says that those communities which were not traditionally "upper caste", have now risen economically and are part of the power structure. Marathas, for instance, are new entrants to a higher social standing. Keen to maintain this, they ally themselves with the upper castes and prove their allegiance by stomping on the traditional underdog, Dalits.


Another commonality in the cases is the police baulking at registering cases under the Prevention of Atrocities Act. They either dismiss serious crimes as trivial offences (like the police inspector in Shirdi who told Sagar's family that it was just a bar brawl) or introduce a "Dalit-boy-upper-caste-girl" love angle in order to lessen the gravity of crimes that actually have their roots in land-grabbing, sheer assertion of caste dominance, or rage by dominant castes at what they see as "defiance" or the lower castes "getting above themselves". The Dalit writer and activist Anand Teltumbde said: "This comes handy for the police to divert attention and create indignation among the people. It is a typical ploy which extends to the judicial process too that the atrocity was not due to caste motive. Khairlanji [where four members of a Dalit family were killed in 2006] exemplifies it wherein the lower court dismissed the argument that there was caste motive in the gory incident."


Criminal offences

Some of the fatal crimes against Dalits in the past 12 months are listed below.


On April 3, 2014, a former sarpanch named Ganesh Chavan in Jalna district assaulted a Dalit called Manoj Kasab. The reason: Kasab became sarpanch thanks to reservation and Chavan was offended that he had been "usurped" by a Dalit. Kasab's assailant was a Maratha and he was booked under the Prevention of Atrocities Act along with 10 others who had helped Chavan.


On April 25, 2014, Umesh Agale was stabbed to death in a village in Aurangabad district. He was suspected of having an affair with an upper-caste girl. Three Maratha men lured Agale out of his house on the pretext of talking to him, killed him in the adjoining fields and dumped his body in a well. There was initial resistance to treating this as a caste atrocity case, but the police later registered it as such and booked the three men.


Three days later, on April 28, a teenaged Dalit boy was strangled to death and his body was hung from a tree in Ahmednagar district because he spoke to a Maratha girl. The boy, Nitin Aghe, was taken from his school by the girl's brother and another man, beaten and then strangled. Initial investigations did not even treat the death as murder, let alone a caste crime, but later this was reversed and a case was registered under the Prevention of Atrocities Act.


On May 1, 2014, Manik Udage was crushed to death in a stone quarry by four Maratha men from his own village in Pune district because they objected to the celebrations Udage had planned for Ambedkar Jayanti.


It took a year for the police to register a case under the Prevention of Atrocities Act.


A fortnight later, on May 16, Sanjay Khobragade, a Dalit activist in his forties, was set on fire in Gondia district. He was trying to prevent a higher-caste family from usurping land set aside for a Buddha vihar.


Despite 90 per cent burns, Khobragade managed to give a dying declaration to the police implicating six people of a Powar family. They were charged under the Prevention of Atrocities Act but were set free when a new angle was "discovered", in which the victim's wife was apparently engaged in a liaison with someone else.


October 21, 2014, saw three of a family butchered in caste violence in Ahmednagar district. Sanjay Jadhav, his wife, Jayshree, and their son Sunil were murdered in the early hours of the day. When farm labourers told Sanjay Jadhav's brother they had not turned up for work, a search was initiated. The mutilated bodies of the men were found strewn around in a farm. The woman's body was found with a deep injury on the head. The cause of this violence was attributed to an alleged alliance between Sunil and an upper-caste girl. No immediate arrests were made, but later the very man who had filed the first information report (FIR) was arrested. He was the deceased man's nephew and the police maintain that the reason for the crime was a family dispute. Once this arrest was made, the charge of "family dispute" safely took the case out of the realm of the Prevention of Atrocities Act. Nothing more was heard about the initial claim that there was an alliance between Sunil and an upper-caste girl.


On January 1, 2013, Ahmednagar district saw the murder of three Dalit men who worked as safai kamgars (cleaners). Sandip Dhanwar, Sachin Dharu and Rahul Kandare were called one morning to clean a septic tank at the house of Prakash Darandale, a Maratha. At 8 p.m., a relative of Dhanwar received a call from the police saying he had drowned in the septic tank. Knowing two other people had accompanied Dhanwar, the relative asked the caller about their whereabouts. He was told they had already left. A few hours later, he received another call from the police informing him that the other two were found dead in a well. The bodies of these two were mutilated, with Dharu's head and limbs severed from the body. Cases under the Prevention of Atrocities Act were registered and the police said that it was related to honour killing because of some involvement with an upper-caste girl.


These cases are just the reported ones. There are many that have not ended fatally and many remain unreported because of the tedium of the legal process as well as dominant caste arrogance that deters people from pursuing justice. Dr V.A. Ramesh Nathan, general secretary of the National Dalit Movement for Justice, says that at the national level conviction takes place in fewer than 10 per cent of the cases under the Prevention of Atrocities Act. Compare this with the 44 per cent conviction rate for cases filed under the Indian Penal Code (IPC). He attributes the low percentage of convictions to poor investigation and implementation of the law.


"In almost all cases, counter-cases are filed and the victim or their family is forced to withdraw their original case. In the special courts there is a nexus [between the authorities]. They do things like not filing the charge sheet on time," said Nathan.


If the Prevention of Atrocities Act is to be seen as the deterrent it is meant to be, then cases need to be resolved with some speed. While constitutional and legal means of justice exist for Dalits, their implementation is sluggish. For many this is as good as no law.



News Monitored by Girish Pant & AJEET



.Arun Khote
On behalf of
Dalits Media Watch Team
(An initiative of "Peoples Media Advocacy & Resource Centre-PMARC")

Pl visit on FACEBOOK : 
Peoples Media Advocacy & Resource Centre- PMARC has been initiated with the support from group of senior journalists, social activists, academics and  intellectuals from Dalit and civil society to advocate and facilitate Dalits issues in the mainstream media. To create proper & adequate space with the Dalit perspective in the mainstream media national/ International on Dalit issues is primary objective of the PMARC.

No comments: