Tuesday, October 27, 2026

Bihar State Road Transport "Corporation and State of Bihar, cannot be permitted to defeat the legitimate and equitable claims of the workmen", Bihar Chief Secretary asked to be in Supreme Court, judgement authored by Justice Rajiv Roy set aside

In Bihar State Rajya Path Parivartan Nigam Karamchari Sangathan vs. The State of Bihar & Ors. (2026), after the lapse of a period of three months from the date of its judgement dated May 22, 2026, Supreme Court's Division Bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Aparesh Kumar Singh passed a 2-page long order dated October 26, 2026, wherein it has directed that if compliance affidavit is not filed before December 14, 2026, the Chief Secretary of the State of Bihar shall remain present before the Court. If the compliance is made, the personal presence would not necessary. The State prayed for six weeks’ time to ensure compliance of the directions as contained in judgment dated May 22, 2026. Earlier, on September 25, 2026, the State had prayed for four weeks’ time to file status report. Prior to that Court's direction dated May 22, 2026 reads; "The State of Bihar shall file a compliance affidavit by 31st August, 2026. List on 1st September, 2026 for perusal of the said compliance affidavit." 

In its final order dated May 22, 2026, Supreme Court has concluded:  23. The plea of financial incapacity, raised by the Corporation and State of Bihar, cannot be permitted to defeat the legitimate and equitable claims of the workmen, particularly when the inability of the Corporation to implement the second phase of regularization was neither attributable to any fault on the part of the workmen nor within their control. The concerned workers had devoted the most productive years of their service career to the Corporation with a legitimate expectation that the settlement entered 10 into pursuant to the directions of this Court would be honoured in its true letter and spirit. 24. Prolonged denial of fair and reasonable compensation to the concerned workmen has resulted in grave injustice, especially when many of them have either attained advanced age or are no longer in a position to secure alternative means of livelihood. In such circumstances, the perceived reference to the alleged financial distress of the Corporation cannot constitute a valid ground to deny the affected workmen just, fair and equitable monetary relief. The Corporation being an entity under the pervasive control of the State of Bihar, the latter is under a moral, legal and constitutional obligation to satisfy and indemnify the legitimate claims of the destitute workers. 25. In view of the aforesaid discussion, and upon balancing the competing considerations arising in the present matter, including the prolonged service rendered by the concerned workmen on the one hand and the precarious financial condition of the Corporation on the other, we deem it appropriate to direct the State of Bihar to pay a lump sum amount 11 of Rs. 7,50,000/- (Rupees Seven Lakh Fifty Thousand only) to each of the 330/338 members of the appellant-Union towards full and final settlement of their claims. The State of Bihar shall ensure that the aforesaid amount is disbursed to the concerned members of the appellant-Union within a period of three months from today. 26. Accordingly, the impugned judgment and order is set aside and the appeal is allowed. 27. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of. 28. The State of Bihar shall file a compliance affidavit by 31st August, 2026. List on 1st September, 2026 for perusal of the said compliance affidavit. 26. Accordingly, the impugned judgment and order is set aside and the appeal is allowed." The impugned judgement was authored by Justice Rajiv Roy as part of a Division Bench. 

The other four respondents are: 2.The Principal Secretary, Transport Department, Bihar, 3. The Bihar State Road Transport Corporation, through its Managing Director, 4. The Administrator, Bihar State Road Transport Corporation and 5. The Labour Commissioner, Bihar. 

In Bihar State Rajya Path Parivartan Nigam Karamchari Sangathan vs. The State of Bihar & Ors. (2026), Supreme Court's Division Benc of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta granted leave by its 11-page long final order dated May 22, 2026. The appellant, Bihar State Rajya Path Parivahan Nigam Karamchari Sangathan had approached the Court by way of the instant appeal, by special leave under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, assailing the judgment dated October 5, 2023 authored by Justice Rajiv Roy as part of the Division Bench of the Patna High Court. By the impugned judgment and order, Justice Roy dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant-Union and declined to interfere with order dated 2nd April, 2018 passed by Justice Ashwini Kumar Singh the Single Judge in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 12436 of 2017, whereby the writ petition instituted by the appellant-Union came to be dismissed. The said writ petition had been filed seeking quashing of the order dated 23rd September, 2016 passed by the Labour Commissioner, Bihar. 4. The appellant-Union is a registered union espousing the cause of the workmen who had been engaged by the Bihar State Road Transport Corporation3 on casual/ad-hoc basis during the period between the years 1980 and 1985. At the relevant point of time, the appellant-Union represented approximately 925 such workmen who 2 Hereinafter, referred to as “High Court”. 3 Hereinafter, referred to as “Corporation”. 3 had been continuously discharging duties under the Corporation for several years. 

The grievances of the aforesaid workmen first came to be considered in proceedings culminating in Civil Appeal No. 1509 of 1987 before the Supreme Court, wherein the Court vide order dated December 16, 1987 directed the Corporation to frame an appropriate scheme for regularization of the concerned casual labourers and to ensure payment of wages to them at par with regular employees with effect from 1st January, 1987. Pursuant to the directions of the Court, a settlement/agreement dated July 11, 1988 came to be executed between the management of the Corporation and the appellant-Union, whereby it was agreed that the process of regularization would be undertaken in two phases. In terms of the first phase of the aforesaid settlement, 425 conductors/clerks and 162 casual helpers came to be regularized in service. However, the remaining approximately 500 workmen, who were to be considered in the second phase of 4 regularization, were never absorbed into regular service, despite rendering long and continuous service under the Corporation. The implementation of the second phase of regularization could not materialize on account of the deteriorating financial condition of the Corporation. Owing to the mounting financial crisis, the Corporation progressively curtailed the engagement of casual labourers and, by the year 1995, the availability of work for such employees had substantially diminished. Ultimately, by order dated September 2, 2009, the services of the remaining workmen were dispensed with on the ground of severe financial crisis and inability of the Corporation to sustain their engagement. 

Being aggrieved by the aforesaid action, the concerned workmen and the appellant-Union initiated various legal proceedings challenging the termination/removal of the workmen from service. However, the reliefs sought by the appellant-Union did not find favour before the Courts concerned. Thereafter, the matter reached the Supreme Court in Special Leave Petition (C) No. 22998 of 2010, wherein the Court, while taking note of the prolonged service rendered by the workmen as well as the inability of the Corporation to implement the settlement dated July 11, 1988, observed that the issue may appropriately be resolved through determination of a one-time settlement in lieu of regularization. Accordingly, the Labour Commissioner, Bihar, was directed to examine the matter and determine suitable compensation payable to the concerned workmen. Pursuant thereto, the Labour Commissioner, Bihar, passed an order dated September 23, 2016 directing payment of lump sum compensation to the concerned workmen while treating the matter as one of retrenchment under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. However, according to the appellant-Union, the amounts so determined ranged merely between Rs.10,000/- and Rs. 55,000/- approximately, despite the fact that several workmen had rendered nearly 19 years of continuous service under the Corporation. 

The appellant-Union challenged the aforesaid order dated September 23, 2016 and consequent determination of the aforesaid amounts, on the ground that the compensation awarded was wholly illusory, arbitrary and shockingly inadequate, having no reasonable nexus with the length of service rendered by the workmen, the legitimate expectations arising from the settlement dated July 11, 1988, and the repeated assurances extended over the years regarding their absorption in regular service. The challenge raised by the appellant-Union, however, came to be rejected by the Single Judge of the High Court in Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 12436 of 2017, and the Letters Patent Appeal preferred against, being LPA No. 593 of 2018, was also dismissed by the Division Bench of the High Court vide the impugned judgment and order dated October 5, 2023. Being aggrieved, the appellant-Union approached the Supreme Court by way of appeal by special leave. 

The counsel for the appellant-Union submitted that Justice Roy of the High Court, while passing the impugned judgment, failed to appreciate that the controversy before it was no longer confined to the issue of regularization, which had attained finality in earlier proceedings, but rather pertained to the fairness, adequacy and reasonableness of the one-time settlement and compensation determined pursuant to the directions issued by this Court. It was submitted that the appellant-Union is presently espousing the cause of approximately 330/338 surviving members/workmen, many of whom had devoted prime years of their working lives in service of the Corporation without being accorded the status and benefits of regular employees. 

It is pertinent to note that during the course of present proceedings i.e., February 16, 2026, the Supreme Court observed that "payment of a lump sum amount of Rs. 10 lakhs to each of the affected workmen may constitute a fair and reasonable settlement in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case." However, this proposal was opposed by the counsel appearing on behalf  of the Corporation as well as the State of Bihar on the ground that the financial condition of the Corporation continues to remain extremely precarious and burdened with substantial accumulated losses, thereby rendering it incapable of bearing any further financial liability. 

Justice Nath observed: "The controversy involved in the present matter cannot be examined in a purely technical or adversarial manner. The case pertains to a group of workmen who had continued in service of the Corporation for a considerable length of time pursuant to arrangements and assurances extended by the employer itself and whose claims have remained unresolved for decades despite repeated rounds of litigation and intervention by this Court. 22. In the aforesaid backdrop, we are of the considered view that the stand adopted by the Corporation and the State of Bihar is wholly untenable in facts and law and contrary to the Fundamental Right to Life guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The workmen represented by the appellant-Union had rendered long, continuous and uninterrupted service to the Corporation and had continued to discharge duties against perennial and regular nature of work. Despite the settlement dated 11th July, 1988 and the assurances regarding their absorption, the concerned workmen were ultimately denied the benefits of regularization and were left remediless for several years."

Earlier, in its 18-page long judgement dated October 5, 2023, Patna High Court's Division Bench of Chief Justice K. Vinod Chandran and Justice Rajiv Roy had dismissed the LPA and upheld the 13-page long judgement dated April 2, 2018 by Justice Ashwani Kumar Singh. Justice Roy had authored the Division Bench judgement. Justice Singh had granted "liberty to the petitioner to challenge the order passed by the Commissioner of Labour in accordance with law before the appropriate forum."

The appellant-Union is representing the casual workers engaged in the Bihar State Road Transport Corporation. The case as narrated by the appellant is that altogether 925 persons were appointed in ‘the Corporation’ on the casual basis prior to 1985. Out of them, 425 were regularized in the first phase subsequent to the settlement arrived at in the year 1988, but the remaining 500 members who were supposed to be taken in the second phase were not considered by ‘the Corporation’. 

The first round of litigation started in the year 1985 when the petitioner-Union approached this Court by filing writ application bearing CW.J.C No. 3460 of 1985 with the prayer for regularization of their services. The said writ application was dismissed vide an order dated September 2, 1985. Against the said order of dismissal, Civil Appeal no. 1509 of 1987 was preferred before the Supreme Court of India. It was disposed of on December 16, 1987 with three fold directions:
a) to prepare reasonable scheme for the regularization of casual employees who have been working for more than a year;
b) the salaries and allowances be paid to them at par with the minimum pay in the pay scale of regularly paid employees in the corresponding cadres of the Corporation;
c) to pay all the arrears payable pursuant to the order.

Subsequent to the said order, a Review petition (C) no. 381/1988 was preferred by respondents. However, side by side the respondent authorities also took steps for an amicable settlement with the petitioner-Union and finally they entered into an agreement/settlement on July 11, 1988 whereby it was agreed to regularize 425 casual labourers in the first phase. In view of the compromise arrived at between the parties, Supreme Court declined to interfere/entertain the review application and disposed it of on October 30, 1990.  However, as the respondents failed to act further, a letter was sent by the Union to the then the Chief Justice, Patna High Court. It came to be registered as CWJC No. 973 of 1993 which was disposed of vide an order dated February 21, 1994 directing the respondents to implement the order of Supreme Court in four months. The SLP preferred by the State Government against the order dated February 21, 1994 was also dismissed by the Supreme Court. However, as no regularization process took place and ‘the Corporation’ vide an order dated September 2, 2009 instead decided for the removal of the casual workers w.e.f September 10, 2009 citing its financial condition. The claim of the petitioner-Union is/was that till then, work was being taken by ‘the Corporation’ intermittently and they were not permanently disengaged at any point of time. Being aggrieved with the said order dated September 2, 2009, C.W.J.C No. 12926 of 2009 was preferred before Patna High Court. It was disposed of vide an order dated October 6, 2009 with the observations/directions that ‘the Corporation’ will look into the aspect that no statutory mandate is violated and if any person claims that they have been paid less than the Minimum Wages Act, then it would be open for them to raise those claims and ‘the Corporation’ would be bound to consider the same. The other observations given by the Writ Court against the removal was that it would be open for the employees to take steps under the Industrial Dispute Act. Aggrieved by the said order dated October 6, 2009 passed in C.W.J.C No. 12926 of 2009, the appellant -Union filed LP.A no. 1412 of 2009 which too came to be dismissed vide an order dated April 8, 2010. Against the said order dated April 8, 2010 passed in LP.A No. 1412 of 2009, appellant-Union preferred SLP (Civil) No. 22998 of 2010. It was disposed of on February 16, 2015/February 16, 2015 with the observation that appellant may approach the Commissioner of Labour for settlement of their claims. Thereafter, the appellant-Union filed Contempt Petition (Civil) no. 481 of 2016 before the Supreme Court as respondents were not taking steps towards the compliance of order dated February 16, 2015/March 16, 2015 passed in SLP (Civil) No. 22998 of 2010. During the pendency of contempt application, Commissioner of Labour, Bihar Patna passed the impugned order dated September 23, 2016 with the direction to retrench the members of appellant-Union under 25 N(A) of Industrial Disputes Act with following observations:
(i) the dues payment will be made in accordance with the Minimum Wages Act as fixed by the Bihar Government;
(ii) Gratuity amount will be paid in terms of payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. 

Thereafter the contempt application taken up was directed to be closed by the Supreme Court vide an order dated July 17, 2017 after taking note of the said order dated September 23, 2016 passed by Labour Commissioner with further observation: It would be open for the petitioner to challenge the order passed by the Commissioner of Labour in accordance with law. The appellant-petitioner thereafter moved in writ
petition before the Patna High Court with the following prayers:
i) to issue writ in the nature of certiorari to quash memo no. 3/D- 39/2015-310 dated 23.09.2016 passed by the Labour Commissioner, Bihar (respondent no 5) in an arbitrary manner and misconstruing/misinterpreting the order dated 16.02.2015 read with order dated 16.03.2015 passed by Hon'ble Apex court in Special Leave to Appeal (C) no. 22998/2010 by invoking section 25 N (a) of the Industrial Dispute Act to retrench them and further prayer to make payment of due amount on the basis of minimum wages fixed by Bihar Government.
ii) to issue writ to quash the newspaper publication issued by ‘the Corporation’ in consequence of the order dated 23.09.2016 passed by respondent no. 5;
iii) to issue further writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents especially respondent no. 5 to Act in a manner circumscribed by Hon'ble Apex Court in Special Leave to Appeal (C) no. 22998/2010 an well as the earlier settlement made in the year 1988 and 1990.
iv) to issue writ in the nature of mandamus directing respondent no. 5 to consider the settlement of the year 1988 and 1990 and if "corporation" is proposing for one time settlement then the long service rendered be also considered and the settlement be done after giving a proper and reasonable compensation so that they may be able to maintain their livelihood. The matter was taken up by the writ court on April 2, 2018 and having gone through the facts of the case, the Single Judge dismissed the writ petition. This judgement was upheld by Justice Roy as part of the Division Bench, which has now been set aside by the Supreme Court.  

No comments: