Saturday, October 24, 2026

Contraband not recovered from appellant, "no useful purpose served in carrying out a prosecution against the appellant": Supreme Court

In Sanjana Bhaskaran vs. State of Telangana & Anr. (2026), the Supreme Court's Division Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran passed a 5-page long order dated October 9, 2026, wherein, it concluded:"6. Trite is the principle that no confession can be relied on. The contraband also having not been recovered from the appellant, we are of the opinion that there would be no useful purpose served in carrying out a prosecution against the appellant. We are of the opinion that the Police should be more sensitive in such matters, especially since the appellant, in one way, is a victim being last in the chain of supply. Prosecuting such victims can have a spiralling effect and incarceration pending trial, can lead to more disastrous consequences of the victim joining the supply chain, by reason only of associations developed in prisons. Curbing availability and breaking the supply chain shall be the focus and not merely punishing the user, who is actually the victim....8. Insofar as the appellant is concerned, her arraignment in the Sessions Case stands quashed. We are not persuaded to subject the appellant to a de-addiction process, especially since we find no complicity insofar as the appellant is concerned with respect to the allegations raised of conscious possession of narcotics. 9. The appeal stands allowed."

The appellant was the 4th accused in a case registered under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 and the allegation was that she had received a packet from the co-accused; two of whom were apprehended along with her, and the packet contained dried leaves and buds with strong odour, which was later identified as marijuana. The appellant was subjected to a medical test, wherein she was detected to have used marijuana. The alleged sellers of marijuana near the educational institution were apprehended with much more quantity of marijuana, which was kept in the Scooty on which they came to the spot, from where they were apprehended. The co-accused disclosed the names of their supplier, who was also arrayed in the case.

The order records:"3. Insofar as the appellant is concerned, even according to the statements of the officers of the police team, there was no recovery made from her or from the bag which she carried. In fact, the specific case is that the Sub-Inspector of Police, Nandigama Police Station, received a credible information that two persons were coming to sell marijuana near a college. The same was intimated to the superior officers and deputation of two government employees were sought from the Tahsildar to act as panch witnesses. The police team along with independent witnesses reached the spot at about 02:30 pm. At 03:00 pm, two persons arrived on a Scooty and halted at a distance of 100 meters from where the police team was carrying out surveillance. The appellant is said to have emerged from the college, approached the two persons who were standing near the Scooty, who handed over a cover to the girl, which was kept in her bag.  4. The police immediately pounced on the three and the allegation is that the appellant produced the cover from her bag; voluntarily. In fact, when the police saw the appellant putting the cover in the bag, they should have informed her about her right to be examined before a Magistrate and then they should have carried out the search, if she consents to that. The version that the girl produced the cover voluntarily, raises a suspicion also with respect to the knowledge of the appellant, that there was a contraband in the cover. In fact, the entire case set up against the appellant was based on the confession, said to have been made by the co-accused; the two persons who had commercial quantity of marijuana with them and the confession of the appellant herself."

The Court clarified that it had not looked at the case of the other accused who were arrayed in S.C. NDPS No. 91/2025 pending before the Special Sessions Judge, Fast Track Court, Rangareddy District, LB Nagar.  

No comments: