In The State of Bihar Through Vigilance, Bihar vs. Phulpari Kumari (2026), Supreme Court's Division Bench of Justices K.V. Viswanathan and Arun Palli passed a 6-page long order dated November 2, 2026, wherein, it granted leave. The order concluded: "....we find that the reasoning of the High Court is totally untenable. In a prosecution under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Act, the accused is called upon to explain allegations with regard to owning assets disproportionate to known sources of income. Merely showing certain press release and circulars permitting the holding of gold to a certain extent will not amount to accounting for the possession of the said assets. 10. In view of the above, we set aside the impugned order of the High Court and restore to file the order of cognizance dated 28th January, 2021 taken by the Court of Special Judge, Vigilance, Patna in Special Case No. 20 of 2015, arising from P.S. Case No. 37 of 2015. The case shall proceed from that stage....12. The respondent is at liberty to initiate such proceedings as are available in law before the Trial Court, and needless to say that if those proceedings are resorted to, they will be decided uninfluenced by any of the observations in the order of the High Court or in the present order. 13. The Appeal is allowed in the above terms."
The appeal before the Supreme Court had called into question the correctness of the order dated May 14, 2026 passed by Justice Ansul of the Patna High Court. By the said order, the High Court had quashed the order of cognizance dated January 28, 2021 passed by the Special Judge, Vigilance, Patna. On May 11, 2015, a First Information Report was registered at the Vigilance Police Station, Patna, in P.S. Case No. 37 of 2015 against the respondent under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Act as well as her husband for owning assets disproportionate to known sources of income. After obtaining sanction, on July 29, 2020, a chargesheet was filed only against the respondent for the said offences.. On January 28, 2021, the Court of Special Judge, Vigilance, Patna took the cognizance against the respondent. The respondent had challenged the said order in the High Court.
The appellant-State submitted that entitlement to possess gold is one thing, accounting for it when called upon in a prosecution under Section 13(1)(e) read with Section 13(2) of the Act, is a wholly different matter. Phulpari Kumari, the respondent defended the impugned order by Justice Ansul and submitted through her counsel that there were other aspects which will show that the assets were not disproportionate to the known source of income.
Earlier, in Phulpari Kumari vs. The State of Bihar Through Vigilance, Bihar (2026), Justice Ansul of the High Court had passed a 4-page long judgement dated May 14, 2026, wherein, he had concluded:" 5. Learned counsel for the Vigilance submits that Instruction No. 1916 dated 11.05.1994 and Press Release issued by Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Central Board of Direct Taxes dated 01.12.2016 will not be applicable in the case of the petitioner. He has filed counter-affidavit where the details of mode and manner of assessment of gold jewellery has been given but it is categorical case of the Vigilance Department that the Instruction has been issued to the Income Tax Department with reference to possession of gold jewellery. In sum and substance, it is submitted by learned counsel for the Vigilance that the aforesaid Executive Instruction/Guidelines issued by the Government has no application in the present case of the petitioner. 6. In the present case, if the gold is calculated with reference to the aforesaid Circular, the petitioner does not possess more than 750 Grams which is the permissible limit of petitioner. Thus, the Vigilance Department has seized the gold erroneously and has committed error in calculating the weight of the gold jewellery of the petitioner and determining the proportionate assets of the petitioner. 7. In such view of the matter, the order of cognizance dated 28.01.2021 passed by learned Special Judge, Vigilance, Patna in connection with Special Case No. 20 of 2015 arising out of Vigilance P.S. Case No. 37 of 2015 registered for the offences under Sections 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 is quashed so far as the petitioner is concerned. 8. Accordingly, the present application stands allowed." The petitioner had filed the case in the High Court on March 15, 2021. It was registered on September 24, 2021.
On March 13, 2026, the counsel for the Vigilance had sought time to take instruction as to whether Instruction: 1916 dated May 11, 1994 regarding Guidelines for seizure of jewellery and ornaments in course of search vide F. No. 286/63/93-IT (Inv. II), issued by the Secretary, CBDT, Government of India, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, was taken into consideration while calculating disproportionate assets of the petitioner or not. Justice Ansul's order dated March 13, 2026 had stayed the operation of the order dated January 28, 2021 pending before the Special Judge, Vigilance, Patna till the next date of hearing.
The petitioner had approached the High Court praying for quashing of the order of cognizance dated January 28, 2021 passed by Special Judge, Vigilance, Patna in connection with a Special Case of 2015 which arose out of Vigilance P.S. Case of 2015 registered for the offences under Sections 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The petitioner was posted as CDPO Patna. While taking bribe, she was trapped by the Vigilance and the case was registered vide Vigilance P.S. Case No. 54 of 2013. During the search of the house, inventory of other articles was prepared along with several documents showing investment in Bank. Vigilance PS Case No. 37 of 2015 was instituted under Section 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. During the course of enquiry, the D.A. against her husband was found minimal. Therefore, no charge-sheet was submitted against her. The difference between the total income and expenditure of the petitioner during the check period was Rs. 12,71,693/-. The total weight of gold jewellery was 646.400 grams. The case of the petitioner was that the same not only belongs to her but also to her unmarried daughter and other family members.
The counsel for the petitioner relied upon Instruction No. 1916 dated May 11, 1994 and Press Release issued by Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Central Board of Direct Taxes dated December 1, 2016 which prescribes that a married woman was entitled to possess 500 Grams of gold jewellery, unmarried lady was entitled to possess 250 Grams of gold jewellery and male was entitled to possess 100 Grams of gold jewellery. The petitioner was/is a married woman and married woman is entitled to 500 Grams of gold and the petitioner has a daughter who was unmarried on the date of search, i.e., August 17, 2013.
Given the fact that Supreme Court has not passed a detailed order while setting aside the High Court's order, it is difficult to appreciate as to why showing union government's own press release and its circulars "permitting the holding of gold to a certain extent will not amount to accounting for the possession of the said assets." The order should have elaborated as to why union government's own press release and its circulars permitting possession of the gold assets is not enough. The order simply reproduces the detailed submissions by the appellant-State to conclude that High Court's order was "untenable". It does not engage with the submission of the respondent which was accepted by the High Court in paragraph 6 of the impugned order which, the Supreme Court merely reproduced as verbatim: “6. In the present case, if the gold is calculated with reference to the aforesaid Circular, the petitioner does not possess more than 750 Grams which is the permissible limit of petitioner. Thus, the Vigilance Department has seized the gold erroneously and has committee error in calculating the weight of the gold jewellery of the petitioner and determining the proportionate assets of the petitioner.”
The only difference between the order of the Supreme Court and the judgement of the High Court is that the former accepts the submission of the Department of Vigilance, Bihar and the latter accepts the submission of the Child Development Project Officer (CDPO), Patna who manages block-level implementation of the Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) program under the Social Welfare Department, Government of Bihar.
There is a similarity in the order of the Supreme Court and the judgement of the High Court. Both suffer from one of the five kinds of hetvabhasa (insufficient reason used in an inference) systematically identified by the Nyaya school of Indian philosophy as a class of defective reasons. Hetvabhasa is listed as the 13th of the 16 philosophical categories (padarthas) in the opening sūtra (1.1.1) and later in Sutras 1.2.5 through 1.2.9 of the Nyaya Sutras, the ancient Sanskrit text composed by Akṣapada Gautama. When a reason appears valid on the surface but is fundamentally defective, it is called a hetvabhasa ('fallacy of the reason' or 'pseudo-reason'). In Indian logic, hetu means the reason used to prove something and abhasa means appearance. Hetvabhasa is, therefore, a reason that appears valid.
No comments:
Post a Comment