Sunday, November 15, 2026

Supreme Court concludes: High Court cannot direct surrender while rejecting anticipatory bail in complaint cases, refers to "serious problems" in Bihar and Jharkhand

In Om Prakash Chhawnika vs. State of Jharkhand, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 676, the Supreme Court's Division Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and Ujjal Bhuyan delivered a 7-page long order dated April 23, 2026 wherein, it observed: "7. We have noticed that there is a serious problem in two States, viz. the State of Bihar and State of Jharkhand, respectively. We fail to understand that in a private complaint how does the Police involve itself or is concerned, in any manner. What was the basis for the accused to express apprehension that the police would arrest them. 8. In a private complaint when cognizance is taken and process is issued all that the Court would do is to issue summons. We have explained many times in the past the purport of Section 87 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (for short, “the Cr.PC.”)". It concluded:"15. Registry is directed to forward one copy of this order to the Registrar General of the High Court of Bihar and also the Registrar General of the High Court of Jharkhand, respectively who in turn shall place this order before the Hon’ble Chief Justice of the respective High Courts. 16. We also impressed upon the learned counsel appearing for the State to look into this issue and guide the State accordingly. 17. With the aforesaid, the Special Leave Petition stands disposed of." 

Section 87 of the Cr.PC. reads: “87. Issue of warrant in lieu of, or in addition to, summons.—A Court may, in any case in which it is empowered by this Code to issue a summons for the appearance of any person, issue, after recording its reasons in writing, a warrant for his arrest—(a) if, either before the issue of such summons, or after the issue of the same but before the time fixed for his appearance, the Court sees reason to believe that he has absconded or will not obey the summons; or (b) if at such time he fails to appear and the summons is proved to have been duly served in time to admit of his appearing in accordance therewith and no reasonable excuse is offered for such failure.” 

Section 87 empowers the Court to issue warrant in lieu of, or in addition to, summons. However, this power has to be exercised only in two contingencies as explained by the provision itself, i.e, (a) and (b), referred to above, respectively.

Supreme Court observed: "10. Once the Court takes cognizance and issues summons, all that the accused has to do is to appear before that Court and join the proceedings. Why should the accused go before the Sessions Court or the High Court, as the case may be, and pray for anticipatory bail? Police has no power to arrest the accused in a complaint case unless there is a non bailable warrant issued by that Court along with the summons. 11. We may give one another simple illustration. Take a case wherein on a private complaint, the magistrate deems fit to take cognizance under Section 200 of the Cr.PC. but postpones the issue of process till the conclusion of the magisterial inquiry under Section 202 of the Cr.P.C. If a magistrate orders a Police inquiry under Section 202 and asks the police to give a report, then whether in the course of such inquiry, the police can arrest the accused. The answer is an emphatic “NO”, Police has no powers to arrest even during the course of the inquiry under Section 202 of the Cr.PC. 12. The aforesaid aspects need to be kept in mind by the High Courts. Unnecessarily anticipatory bail applications are entertained and when rejected the litigants have to travel all the way upto the highest Court of this Country. We also remind the High Court that the direction issued that the petitioner should surrender and seek regular bail before the Court was also wholly without jurisdiction. 13. If the Court wants to reject the anticipatory bail, it may do so but the Court has no jurisdiction to say that the petitioner should now surrender." 

In the appeal before the Supreme Court, there was a land dispute between the petitioner and Respondent 2, the complainant. The Jharkhand High Court denied anticipatory bail to the petitioner in a complaint case for offences punishable under Sections 323, 420, 467, 468, 471, 120B and 34 Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). 

In Om Prakash Chhawnika @ Om Prakash Chabnika @ Om Prakash Chawnika vs. The State of Jharkhand & Anr. (2025), Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava of the Jharkhand High Court had passed a 1-page long order dated July 4, 2025, wherein, it reproduced his own 2-page long order dated March 13, 2023 which reads: “Petitioner is directed to surrender before the court below and seek regular bail which shall be disposed off on its own merits in accordance with the guidelines laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Satender Kumar Antil Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation & Anr. reported in 2021(10) SCC 773” in the anticipatory bail application being A.B.A. No. 8063 of 2022 which was disposed of. In the July 4, 2025 order, Justice Srivastava concluded:"3. No fresh and new ground has been pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner for entertaining this second Anticipatory Bail Application, therefore, A.B.A No. 2319 of 2025 stands dismissed."

The March 2023 order recorded that the petitioner had submitted that he was falsely implicated in this case. As per complaint petition, the complainant was power of attorney holder of certain disputed land but his possession was always disturbed by the accused person. Several Suits have also been instituted and contested up to the Kolkata High Court since long. Petitioner has also got 110 kattas land out of plot Nos.1608 and 1609 through registered sale deed after paying valuable consideration money. It was also submitted that petitioner is bonafide purchaser having no criminal antecedent. The Additional P.P appearing for the State assisted with counsel for the complainant had opposed the prayer for anticipatory bail of the petitioner and submitted that after taking cognizance of offence only summons was issued against the petitioner for his appearance. Hence, petitioner had no reasonable apprehension of his arrest in this case. Hence, the anticipatory bail of the petitioner may be dismissed. 

Justice Srivastava had observed: "Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it appears that there is sheer land dispute between the parties and civil Suit and Criminal proceedings have been lodged and pending. It further appears that petitioner is bonafide purchaser of some piece of land under dispute and custodial trial is not required in this case. Hence, without expressing any view on the merits of the case, this anticipatory bail application is disposed off" but directed the petitioner to surrender before the court below and seek regular bail. Supreme Court reminded the High Court that the direction issued by it for the petitioner to surrender and seek regular bail before the Court was also wholly without jurisdiction. It adeed: "If the Court wants to reject the anticipatory bail, it may do so but the Court has no jurisdiction to say that the petitioner should now surrender."  


No comments:

Post a Comment