In Mukesh Kumar @ Mukesh Kumar Sarraf vs. The State of Bihar & Anr. (2026), Supreme Court's Division Bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran passed a 3-page long order dated October 30, 2026, wherein, it concluded:"4. After rejecting the anticipatory bail, the Learned Single Judge of the High Court regretfully went overboard. It was found that the petitioner appears to be involved in large-scale monetary transactions and deemed it appropriate to direct the Income Tax Department and the Sales Tax Department to furnish the details regarding the tax assessed and paid by the petitioner before the
District Court. The State also does not support such direction. While considering bail applications, the High Court should either allow it or reject it and there is no point in making such order involving tax departments, who have a robust mechanism in place to find out evasion and curb it as also compensate the State by mulcting tax, interest and penalty. The Court in bail applications is concerned only with the culpability and never takes an adversarial role against the accused unless a case reveals such an apparent and compelling circumstance. 5. In the present case, we prima facie find that a commercial transaction was attempted to be converted into criminal liability. The Learned Counsel for the respondents submits that criminal antecedents of the petitioner should also be looked into. The present case was one of advancing of money for purchase of property secured by blank cheques which on presentation were dishonoured with endorsement “insufficient funds”. We are not informed of any proceedings under the NI Act or any Civil Suit having been filed for recovery of amounts. In above circumstances, we cannot but prima facie find that initiation of criminal proceeding is a strong arm tactic. 6. On a prima facie consideration of the material on record, we are of the opinion that the petitioner can be granted anticipatory bail. 7. Accordingly, we direct that, in the event of his arrest in connection with the offences referred to above, he shall be released on bail, subject to such terms and conditions as the Investigating Officer (for short, “I.O.”) may deem fit to impose and subject further to his continued cooperation in the investigation. 8. Upon being released on bail by the I.O., the petitioner shall, pursuant to any direction issued by the I.O. or summons issued by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Buxar (the jurisdictional court), appear before the jurisdictional court, furnish bail bonds, and ensure due appearance during the trial. 9. With the aforesaid, the petition stands disposed of."
The petitioner was denied anticipatory bail by Justice Purnendu Singh of Patna High Court. The counsel for the petitioner had challenged the impugned order on various grounds, including that inclusion of Section 138 of NI Act in an FIR registered and investigated by Police, alleging it to be wholly without jurisdiction and vitiating the proceedings to that extent, the FIR came to be registered after an unexplained
delay of more than three years and the dispute between the parties arises out of financial transaction and monetary dealings, which are civil in nature.
Earlier, in Mukesh Kumar @ Mukesh Kumar Sarraf vs. The State of Bihar & Anr. (2026), Justice Singh of the High Court had passed a 7-page long order dated May 7, 2026, wherein, he concluded:"8. What further emerges from the transaction details brought on record by way of Annexure P/4 is that the petitioner appears to be involved in large-scale monetary transactions. However, except for one entry relating to GST charges amounting to Rs. 94.40 towards cheque book charges and another amount of Rs. 2,292.82 charged by the Bank towards cash and RTGS transactions, there appears to be no clear disclosure regarding the nature and source of the transactions reflected in the account. In such circumstances, this Court deems it proper to direct the Income Tax Department to furnish details regarding the tax assessed and paid by the petitioner for the preceding six financial years up to the current financial year. Similarly, the State Tax Department is directed to furnish details relating to the Central GST, as well as, State GST paid by the petitioner in respect of any goods or business transactions before the learned District Court within a period of three weeks. The learned District Court upon receipt of the relevant information, shall pass a fresh order in accordance with law without being prejudiced by its earlier order dated 25.11.2025, rejecting the prayer for bail of the petitioner forthwith, preferably within one week. 9. Let a copy of this order be communicated to the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Bihar. 10. The present bail application stands disposed of."
The petitioner had approached the High Court seeking pre-arrest bail in connection with Buxar Nagar Thana P.S. Case No. 415 of 2024 registered for the offence(s) punishable under Sections 406, 467, 468, 471/34 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 138 of N.I. Act. As per the allegation made in the FIR, the informant paid an advance amount of Rs.60 lakhs to Mukesh Kumar Sarraf (the petitioner), his brother Randhir Sarraf, and his father Vijay Sarraf for the purchase of a property. Subsequently, upon inquiry, the informant discovered that the said property was disputed and encumbered with several legal issues. Thereafter, the informant approached the petitioner and demanded refund of the aforesaid amount of Rs.60 lakhs. In response, the petitioner issued five cheques of Rs.12 lakhs each, totaling Rs.60 lakhs. However, when the said cheques were presented for encashment, they were dishonoured by the bank, compelling the informant to lodge the present FIR.
The counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner, submitted that the petitioner was innocent and was falsely implicated in the case. It was submitted that it was not disputed that the informant had advanced a sum of Rs. 26,95,000/- to the petitioner through bank transactions. However, it was falsely alleged that the petitioner, along with his family members had induced the informant to invest the said amount in Axis Bank under a scheme namely “Savings–Easy Access” bearing Account No. 922010053439734 for the period commencing from April 1, 2023 to December 31, 2023. It was also submitted that all transactions are duly reflected and verified from the bank statements relating to the said account. The petitioner was ready and willing to return the entire amount claimed by the informant, subject to proper verification of the mode and manner through which the remaining amount of Rs. 26,95,000/- was alleged to have been transferred or paid, and therefore, the petitioner seeks his release on pre-arrest bail.
The counsel appearing on behalf of O.P. No. 2, submitted that the informant is an ex-serviceman and that the petitioner, in connivance with his family members, dishonestly induced him to part with a sum of Rs. 60 lakhs on the pretext of providing a property. It was submitted that despite receiving the said amount, neither was any specific property disclosed nor has the amount been returned to the informant. It was also submitted that the petitioner had issued five cheques of Rs. 12 lakhs each, totalling Rs. 60 lakhs, towards repayment of the amount received from the informant. However, upon presentation, all the cheques were dishonoured by the bank. The counsel also submitted that the petitioner had three criminal antecedents, out of which two are of similar nature, being habitually involved in the offences. It was, therefore, contended that a clear case of cheating and fraud was made out against the petitioner and, as such, he don’t deserve to be released on pre-arrest bail.
Ajit Kumar, the APP for the State opposed the prayer for grant of pre-arrest bail. He submitted that the petitioner by way of Annexure P/4 had brought certain transaction which cannot relate that the same was between the informant. The informant though had filed a counter affidavit being an ex-service man has not given description regarding his bank account. It is admitted by the parties that for total amount of rupees sixty lacs, as claimed by the informant, the petitioner has issued five cheques, amounting to rupees twelve lacs each. Referring to Annexure P/4, the counsel submitted that the complicity of the petitioner along with the informant cannot be denied, considering that the scheme in which the petitioner and O.P. No.2 both have invested which is run by the Axis Bank and from the statement brought on record, it appears that name of scheme is “Saving-Easy Access”. O.P. No.2/the informant has also contributed in the said account, opened in the name of Mukesh Kumar (petitioner), Old Allmuniam Factory, Naibajar, Buxar. The counsel also submitted that it cannot be said that both the parties have jointly proceeded to commit fraud with the State Government in payment of tax dues on account of business transaction which may be in respect of Central GST, as well as, State GST. He further submitted that the transaction reflects for the period April 1, 2023 to December 31, 2023 was of huge amount and such huge amount cannot be in respect of any simple business run by the parties. In these backgrounds, the counsel submitted that the petitioner did not deserve to be released on pre-arrest bail, as he had not come before the High Court with clean hands.
Justice Singh observed:"....this Court finds that the informant claims to have transferred certain amounts into the petitioner of the petitioner in a scheme namely “Saving Easy Access” which is verifiable from the account opened in the Axis Bank (Annexure P/4). This Court has also perused the details of the transactions and the manner in which deposits were made into the account of the petitioner, as well as, the pattern in which amounts were credited and debited therefrom. The petitioner has specifically marked certain entries in the bank statement issued by the Bank to show deposits allegedly made by the informant on different dates. The transactions pertain to the period from 01.04.2023 to 31.12.2023, during which an amount of Rs. 1,12,10,788.07 was debited and an amount of Rs. 1,12,11,302/- was credited in the said account. From the nature and volume of the transactions reflected in the account statement, this Court is of the prima facie view that the petitioner cannot be said to be merely an ordinary land broker his past record is also not sound. It further appears that substantial amounts have been withdrawn in cash and transactions have also been carried out with certain entities and organizations such as Chaitanya Federation, Shaker Traders, Ujjivan Small Finance Bank Limited and other such concerns."
No comments:
Post a Comment