In Nirmala Kumari vs. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, (Home) Police Department, Bihar & Ors. (2026), Patna High Court's Division Bench of Chief Justice V. Kameswar Rao and Justice Partha Sarthy delivered a 22-page long judgement dated November 5, 2026, wherein, it concluded:"26. From the above, it is clear that unless the conclusions drawn are wholly unreasonable and suffers from legal infirmity, the Appellate Court would refrain from interfering with the findings so recorded. 27. It also follows the power has to be exercised with restraint keeping in mind that the purpose of such jurisdiction is to correct errors which are apparent and substantial and not to undertake a fresh appreciation of the entire matter. 28. Though the learned counsel for the appellant has also relied upon other judgments which we have noted above but having considered the latest position of law on the issue in question, we are of the view that the conclusion drawn by the learned Single Judge in the facts of the case more specifically keeping in view the Bihar Police Manual Clause 573(c) which clearly contemplates the consequence of furnishing false information, we hold there is no error nor it is a case of perverse finding, which calls for interference with the impugned judgment. 29. Accordingly, the Letter Patent Appeal filed by the appellant is dismissed."
Earlier, in Nirmala Kumari vs. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, (Home) Police Department, Bihar & Ors. (2026), Justice Dr. Anshuman of Patna High Court had delivered a 13-page long judgement dated January 5, 2026, wherein, he had concluded:"13. After hearing both the parties and upon perusal of the relevant rules and the judgments reported by counsel for the petitioner and the Respondent-State, this Court reached on the conclusion that the statement made by the petitioner in the verification form is false and the petitioner is not entitled for any relief as per the above facts and circumstances as well as the established law of the land. Hence, this writ petition stands dismissed."
Justice Dr. Anshuman had delivered the judgement upon hearing the writ petition which prayed for issuance of an appropriate order/s direction/s including a writ preferably in the nature of CERTIORARI for quashing the order dated May 15, 19 passed by the DIG, BMP, Ke. Ma. Patna whereby and where under had affirmed the order passed by the Commandant B.M.P. -02, Dihri vide Police order dated November 17, 2018 by which the petitioner had been dismissed from her service as a constable. The petition had sought quashing of the police order communicated by letter dated November 17, 2018 passed by the Commandant, B.M.P.2, Dihari by which the petitioner had been dismissed and to direct the respondents to re-instate the petitioner on the post of constable and make the payment of full pay and salary including arrears of salary if any.
The counsel for the State submitted that the verification form which was annexed to the writ petition was categorical and very much clear as contained in Clause 7 and 8 of the verification form declares that the applicant has never been an accused or served prison sentence and she is neither indebted nor does she face any criminal or civil case which is pending. He submitted that from the pleading of the petitioner itself it was admitted that on the date of filing of the form, there was a criminal case pending against the petitioner.
The counsel of the State relied on the judgment of the Supreme Court of India in Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited & Anr. Vs. Anil Kanwariya reported in (2021) 10 SCC 136 and submitted that the relation between the employer and employee is of trust. In the verification form, the truth has to be narrated, but the petitioner has not narrated the truth, rather, suppressed the fact about the pendency of the case and therefore, according to him in the light of the said decision, the petitioner is not entitled for consideration of her appointment and this aspect has been categorically discussed in the impugned order and the reason has also been assigned in the impugned order.
The counsel also submitted that the said verification has been made in the light of Rule 673(c) of the Bihar Police Manual, 1978. In this background, the case of the petitioner was not entertainable and fit to be dismissed.
Justice Dr. Anshuman recorded: "8. It further transpires to this Court that from the record, it is apparent and admitted position that on the date of filing up of the verification form, there was a criminal case pending against the petitioner about which the statement has been made in the verification form that ‘no’ criminal case is pending and in this view of the matter, it transpires to this Court that the statement of petitioner is false."
The petitioner's counsel had relied on the judgment dated July 21, 2016 in Avtar Singh vs. Union of India & Ors. passed in Special Leave Petition (C) No. 20525 of 2011
Paragraph no. 30(4) of the decision in the case of Avtar Singh reads: “(4) In case there is suppression or false information of involvement in a criminal case where conviction or acquittal had already been recorded before filing of the application/verification form and such fact later comes to knowledge of employer, any of the following recourse appropriate to the case may be adopted:-
(a) In a case trivial in nature in which conviction had been recorded, such as shouting slogans at young age or for a petty offence which if disclosed would not have rendered an incumbent unfit for post in question, the employer may, in its discretion, ignore such suppression of fact or false information by condoning the lapse.
(b) Where conviction has been recorded in case which is not trivial in nature, employer may cancel candidature or terminate services of the employee.
(c) If acquittal had already been recorded in a case involving moral turpitude or offence of heinous/serious nature, on technical ground and it is not a case of clean acquittal, or benefit of reasonable doubt has been given, the employer may consider all relevant facts available as to antecedents, and may take appropriate decision as to the continuance of the employee.”
Justice Dr. Anshuman observed: "0. Upon bare reading of the said observation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Avtar Singh (supra), it is apparent to this Court that in case there is a suppression or false information of involvement in a criminal case where conviction or acquittal had already been recorded before filing of the application/verification form is not the actual fact in the present case. In the present case at the time of filing up the verification form, a false statement has been inserted in the verification
form. Therefore, this judgment shall not help the petitioner in any manner.
The counsel for the State relied on paragraph no. 14 and 15 of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited & Anr. Vs. Anil Kanwariya reported in (2021) 10 SCC 136. It reads: “14. The issue/question may be considered from another angle, from the employer's point of view. The question is not about whether an employee was involved in a dispute of trivial nature and whether he has been subsequently acquitted or not. The question is about the credibility and/or trustworthiness of such an employee who at the initial stage of the employment i.e. while submitting the declaration/verification and/or applying for a post made false declaration and/or not disclosing and/or suppressing material fact of having involved in a criminal case. If the correct facts would have been disclosed, the employer might not have appointed him. Then the question is of TRUST. Therefore, in such a situation, where the employer feels that an employee who at the initial stage itself has made a false statement and/or not disclosed the material facts and/or suppressed the material facts and therefore he cannot be continued in service because such an employee cannot be relied upon even in future, the employer cannot be forced to continue such an employee. The choice/option whether to continue or not to continue such an employee always must be given to the employer. At the cost of repetition, it is observed and as observed hereinabove in catena of decision such an employee cannot claim the appointment and/or continue to be in service as a matter of right. 15. In view of the aforestated facts and circumstances of the case, both, the learned Division Bench as well as the learned Single Judge have clearly erred in quashing and setting aside the order of termination terminating the services of the respondent on the ground of having obtained an appointment by suppressing material fact and filing a false declaration. The order of reinstatement is wholly untenable and unjustified.”
Notably, in paragraph no. 8.8 of the judgment of Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited & Anr. (supra), the said decision of Avtar Singh (supra) has also been discussed. It reads: “8.8 After reproducing and/or reconsidering para 38.5 of the decision in Avtar Singh [Avtar Singh v. Union of India, (2016) 8 SCC 471 : (2016) 2 SCC (L&S) 425], in para 13, this Court observed and held as under : (Abhijit Singh Pawar case [State of M.P. v. Abhijit Singh Pawar, (2018) 18 SCC 733 : (2019) 3 SCC (Cri) 431 : (2019) 2 SCC (L&S) 420], SCC p. 742) “13. In Avtar Singh [Avtar Singh v. Union of India, (2016) 8 SCC 471 : (2016) 2 SCC (L&S) 425], though this Court was principally concerned with the question as to non-disclosure or wrong disclosure of information, it was observed in para 38.5 that even in cases where a truthful disclosure about a concluded case was made, the employer would still have a right to consider antecedents of the candidate and could not be compelled to appoint such candidate.”
Upon hearing both the sides, Justice Dr. Anshuman reached the conclusion that the statement made by the petitioner in the verification form was false and she was not entitled for any relief. Therefore, he dismissed her writ petition.
Subsequent to hearing the intra-court appeal which challenged the judgement by Justice Dr. Anshuman, the Division bench upheld it.
The facts for the purpose of the appeal are, the appellant was selected on the post of Constable on which she joined on August 1, 2018. Before undergoing the training process, she was given a verification form to be filled by her. She filled the same and submitted to the authority concerned on July 5, 2018. Pursuant thereto, she received a show cause notice dated October 11, 2018 stating, therein, that she made a suppression in the said verification form, about pendency of a criminal case against her. The defence of the appellant was that she filled up the verification form ignorantly and not deliberately. It was also stated that the format of the verification form was not clear and for that reason, she filled up the form in such a manner. The show cause notice resulted in her dismissal from service vide order dated November 17, 2018. The appeal filed therefrom before the Appellate Authority had resulted in rejection making the appellant file a writ petition before the High Court being C.W.J.C. No. 5331 of 2019, which was disposed of vide order dated April 8, 2019 directing the Deputy Inspector General of Police to dispose of the appeal of the appellant as expeditiously as possible by taking into consideration all the grounds urged by the appellant in the appeal in accordance with law. Suffice it to state as no order was passed the, appellant preferred M.J.C. No. 2330 of 2019, which was disposed of by the Lok Adalat on September 11, 2021. The appellate order was passed on May 15, 2019.
The counsel for the appellant had relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Avtar Singh vs. Union of India & Ors. in SLP (c) No.20525 of 2011 more specifically, Paragraph No. 30(4), wherein according to the counsel, there is a categorical finding that in case, there is suppression or false information of involvement in a criminal case but where conviction or acquittal had already been recorded before filing of the application/verification form and such fact later comes to knowledge of employer, it is not necessary dismissal must follow. The case of the appellant was also that despite order of the High Court, none of the grounds as urged by the appellant were taken into consideration before passing of the order dated May 15, 2019.
The High Court's Division Bench observed: "21....judgment of the Supreme Court that the Court held complete disclosure in the application for Government employment is not a simple procedural formality, but a basic requirement rooted in fairness, integrity and public trust. The Supreme Court also held while the law recognizes that non-disclosure, depending on the nature of offence and surrounding circumstances, may not be invariably fatal to a candidature, it nevertheless remains a serious lapse. It also held that the gravity is significantly compounded when the non-disclosure is repeated, as it ceases to be accidental or inadvertent and instead reflects deliberate concealment. 22. That apart, the Supreme Court had also noted the consequence of furnishing false information, which is similar to the provision of 573(c) noted by the learned Single Judge in the case in hand. 23. The aforesaid judgment is clearly applicable to the facts of this case."
The Division Bench relied on the decision in the case of Yogeeta Chandra vs. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. in SLP (Civil) Nos.4860-4861/2019, the Supreme Court has in Paragraph Nos. 6 to 8 held as under: “6. In the application form, the applicant, who, as such, applied for the post of a judicial officer was required to disclose certain facts, more particularly, the facts stated in Clause 18 of the Application Form and non-disclosure of true facts and not only that but saying "No" can certainly be said to be suppression of material facts. It was immaterial whether there was a closure report or acquittal or conviction. At this stage, it is required to be noted that the particulars which were asked, whether "did you ever figure as an accused or a complainant in any criminal case? If so, give particulars with result. Therefore, the facturn of figuring the name either as an accused or a complainant in any criminal case was required to be disclosed with full particulars and with result. Therefore, the appellant cannot take the plea and/or defence that as a Closure Report was filed in the complaint in which she was the accused, the same was not required to be disclosed. On the basis of the nature of the allegations in the complaint either as an accused or a complainant, it is ultimately for the employer to take a conscious decision whether to appoint such a person or not. What could be considered while actually appointing a person depends upon the facts and circumstances of each case and it is ultimately for the employer to take a conscious decision. The post which was applied by the appellant was a very important post of judicial officer and therefore, it was expected of a person who applied for the judicial officer to disclose the true and correct facts and give full particulars as asked in the application form. If in the application form itself, she has not stated the true and correct facts and suppressed the material facts, what further things can be expected from her after she was appointed as a judicial officer. 7. From the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court, it appears that it was the case on behalf of the appellant that the services of the appellant could not be put to an end without holding the departmental enquiry under Article 311 of the Constitution of India. However, it is required to be noted that the termination was not on the ground of any misconduct. It was the case of cancellation of the appointment on not disclosing the true and correct facts in the application form. Therefore, as rightly observed by the High Court, there was no question of holding any departmental enquiry under Article 311 of the Constitution of India. 8. Under the circumstances, in the facts and circumstances of the case, no error has been committed by the High Court cancelling her appointment on the ground of not stating the true and correct facts and/or suppression of material facts. We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the High Court. No interference of this Court is called for."
Notably, reference was made to Supreme Court's decision in B. Venkatamuni vs. C.J. Ayodhya Ram Singh & Ors. In (2006) 13 Supreme Court Cases 449, wherein, it has held: “18. ... ... In an intra-court appeal, the Division Bench undoubtedly may be entitled to apprise both questions of fact and law, but the following dicta of this Court in Umabai & Anr. vs. Nilkanth Dhondiba Chavan (Dead) By Lrs. & Anr. [(2005) 6 SCC 243], could not have been ignored by it, whereupon the learned counsel for Respondents relied:-"It may be, as has been held in Asha Devi vs. Dukhi Sao, (1974) 2 SCC 492 that the power of the appellate court in intra-court appeal is not exactly the same as contained in Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure but it is also well known that entertainment of a letters patent appeal is discretionary and normally the Division Bench would not, unless there exist cogent reasons, differ from a finding of fact arrived at by the learned Single Judge. Even as noticed hereinbefore, a court of first appeal which is the final court of appeal on fact may have to exercise some amount of restraint."
No comments:
Post a Comment