Sunday, November 8, 2026

Deadline over but Department of Home, Bihar is yet to file review report in cases prosecution's lapses, inquiries and action, Gorakh Ram, S.H.O., Runisaidpur Police Station is under inquiry

In Subodh Kumar Singh @ Subodh Kumar @ Guddu Singh & Anr. vs. The State of Bihar (2026), Patna High Court's Division Bench of Justices Rajeev Ranjan Prasad and Sunil Dutta Mishra delivered a 43-page long judgement dated September 23, 2026, wherein, it observed:"56. In recent times, this Court has given directions to the Department of Home, Government of Bihar and the DGP, Bihar to look into the matters in which due to lapses on the part of the Investigating Officers, acquittals have taken place. It is not known whether the orders of this Court are being complied with and the directions in this regard have yielded any significant result. In the opinion of this Court, it is high time for the Department of Home. Government of Bihar, the DGP, Bihar and the Director, Directorate of Prosecution to sit together and review its policy in this regard....60. This Court calls upon the Department of Home, Government of Bihar to apprise the Court as to its policy in the matter of reviewing the cases where lapses on the part of the prosecution and the investigation have been pointed out by this Court. In how many cases inquiries have been instituted and with what result be informed to this Court within one month from today. Such report of the Department of Home shall be placed before this Court for perusal even as these appeals stand allowed. 61. Let a copy of this judgment along with records be sent down to the learned trial court. 62. A copy of the judgment be also sent to the Department of Home Government of Bihar, Office of the Director General of Police, Bihar and the Director, Directorate of Prosecution, Government of Bihar." 

More than one month has passed but the High Court's web page with regard to the case in question does not show any filing in compliance with the the Court's judgement by Department of Home, Government of Bihar to apprise the Court as to its policy in the matter of reviewing the cases where lapses on the part of the prosecution, where the investigation have been pointed out by the Court and in how many cases inquiries have been instituted and with what result.  

Justice Prasad had observed: "57. We are of the opinion that the manner in which the Investigation Officer (PW-3) has conducted the investigation, which has been discussed in preceding paragraphs, would be required to be reviewed by a team of Senior Police Officers. 58. We direct the Director General of Police, Bihar to constitute a three-member committee of Senior Police Officers of repute to take a view on the manner in which the investigation was done by the I.O. (PW-3) and based on that report, take an appropriate view of the matter in administrative side within a period of three months from the date of receipt/production of the copy of this Judgment." 

It is not clear as to whether the Director General of Police (DGP), Bihar has constituted the 3-member committee of Senior Police Officers of repute to take a view on the manner in which the investigation was done by Gorakh Ram, the I.O. (PW-3) in compliance with the Court's directions. Based on that report, DGP was directed take an appropriate view of the matter in administrative side within a period of three months. The deadline for doing the same will end on November 23.  

The prosecution case was based on the fardbeyan of Sudhir Singh (PW-2) recorded by S.H.O., Runnisaidpur at 23.12 hours on November 2, 2018 at Ma Janki Hospital, Muzaffarpur, who stated that on November 2, 2018 in the evening, he, his son Deepak Singh and cousin brother Dinkar Singh went where a bridge was being built on the dam. It was stated that the son of the informant and his cousin brother were eating Mudhi-Kachri near the shop, in the meantime, at about 6.00 PM, 11 persons arrived on five motorcycles and started indiscriminate firing on the informant's son and cousin brother. The informant was at some distance, he came and saw that (i) Ranjit Singh (ii) Randhir Singh (iii) Sanjit @Munnu (iv) Vikram Kumar (v) Baidyanath Purvey (vi) Amarnath Kumar (vii) Subodh Kumar (viii) Ayush Kumar @ Golu (ix)Prashant Kumar @ Gudgud (x) Ashik Kumar and (xi) Deepak Kumar started fleeing away towards west direction by motorcycle. The informant tried to chase them but all the persons succeeded in fleeing away. At that time, the informant's uncle Chotan Singh and co-villagers Mukesh Singh, Shivam Kumar, Prince Kumar and Jai Prakash Singh were also present. They were helping the informant in taking his injured son and cousin brother to hospital, they also saw all the accused persons fleeing away and identified them. In course of treatment in S.K.M.C.H., Muzaffapur, the informant's cousin brother died. The treatment of informant's son was going on in Janki Hospital, Muzaffarpur. The son of the informant was in unconscious condition so he said that as and when he would regain consciousness, he will give his statement. All the accused persons were lashed with small weapon in their hand and they fled away towards west direction. Cause of occurrence was that earlier in the year 2014, the informant's wife was murdered by all the accused persons and in course of compromise of that matter, the present occurrence has occurred. The fardbeyan was recorded by S.H.O. of Runisaidpur Police Station, namely, Gorakh Ram (PW-3) on November 2, 2018 at 23:12 hours at Maa Janki Hospital, Muzaffarpur. On the basis of the fardbeyan of the informant (PW-2), Runisaidpur P.S. Case No. 663 of 2018 dated November 3, 2018 was registered under Sections 302/307/34 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act against the accused, namely, (1) Ranjit Singh, (2) Randhir Singh, (3) Sanjit @ Munnu, (4) Vikram Kumar, (5) Baijnath Purvey, (6) Amarnath Kumar, (7) Subodh Kumar, (8) Ayush Kumar, (9) Prabhat Kumar, (10) Aashik Kumar and (11) Deepak Kumar. After investigation, police submitted chargesheet bearing Chargesheet No. 09 of 2019 dated January 19, 2019 against accused, namely, (1) Subodh Kumar, (2) Amarnath Kumar, (3) Baijnath Purvey and (4) Randhir Singh under Section 302/34 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act keeping investigation pending against other accused persons. The Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sitamarhi, vide order dated March 14, 2019 took cognizance of the offence punishable under Section 302/34 IPC and Section 27 of the Arms Act against the appellants and transferred it in the court of SDJM, Sitamarhi for commitment. SDJM, Sitamarhi, vide order dated September 18, 2019, committed the records to the court of Sessions.Charges were read over in Hindi and explained to the appellants to which they pleaded not guilty and claimed to be tried. Accordingly, vide order dated January 13, 2020 charges were framed against them under Sections 302/34 IPC and Section 27(i) of the Arms Act.  In course of trial, the prosecution examined as many as eight witnesses.  

The Division Bench heard the appeals for setting aside the judgment of conviction dated October 18, 2022 and the order of sentence dated October 21, 2022 passed by Additional District and Sessions Judge-XV, Sithamarhi in Sessions Trial No. 419 of 2019 arising out of Runisaidpur P.S. Case No. 663 of 2018. The appellants have been convicted for the offences punishable under Section 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 27(i) of the Arms Act. They were sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life with a fine of Rs10,000/- under Section 302/34 IPC. They were also sentenced to undergo three years imprisonment with a fine of Rs.5,000/-. Both the sentences were to run concurrently.  

Justice Prasad noticed that Sudhir Kumar Singh, the informant (father of the deceased Deepak Kumar), PW-2 could not say whether Daroga Ji had gone to the place of occurrence or not. His son was wearing full shirt and full pant. Daroga Ji had not seized the clothes of his son. In his cross-examination on behalf of Subodh Kumar Singh, he stated that in the said case Subodh Kumar Singh was not an accused. He has though stated in paragraph '14' that at the time of the statement of Deepak he was present but in his fardbeyan he has stated that Deepak was in unconscious condition and the I.O. (PW-3) stated in his deposition that when he went to the hospital, he had not taken any step to record the dying declaration of Deepak. The I.O. has stated in paragraph '41' that Deepak was injured and Sudhir Singh, the informant, had told him that Deepak was not in a position to make his statement. Therefore, the I.O. had recorded the
statement of the informant. In paragraph '18' he claims to have recorded the statement of Deepak but on record, no statement of Deepak had been brought and it was not the part of evidence. Mere recording in paragraph '18' of the case diary that Deepak had made statement cannot be treated as a substantive piece of evidence in this regard. When the High Court looked into the evidence of the I.O. (PW-3), it found that the I.O. has stated in paragraph '45' of his deposition that Chhotan Singh had not given statement before him that near Murhi Kachri shop where bridge was under construction, along with him Jay Prakash Singh, Prince Kumar and Mukesh Kumar were present and that they had seen Deepak Singh, S/o Sudhir Singh and Dinkar Singh @ Sunny eating Murhi Kachri at the shop of Murhi Kachri. The I.O. stated in paragraph '46' that in Murhi Kachri shop he had not found any Machan.

The High Court has recorded the I.O., Gorakh Ram (PW-3) claimed that he had recorded PW-2's fardbeyan at 23:12 hours at Maa Janki Hospital and had investigated the case. During his cross-examination, this witness admits several inspective deficiencies such as the nearby residents were not examined; the shop-keeper/staffs were not properly brought into the ambit of the investigation; the blood stain was not sent to FSL; empty cartridges were not forensically examined; the photographs/video of the blood stained place was not taken and the I.O. had not obtained medical certification of Deepak's fitness before recording his statement or record the time of that statement. PW-3 has confirmed that PW-1 did not give the Police the detailed version subsequently stated in court. He has also confirmed the contents of the informant's fardbeyan regarding being at some distance and seeing the accused fleeing. The testimony of the I.O. (PW-3) would show that he had reached the place of occurrence on the date of occurrence at 19:05
Hours. It means he had reached the place of occurrence in the evening hours itself when the injured persons had already been taken away to PHC, Runisaidpur and SKMCH at Muzaffarpur. The I.O. had not recorded the time of his visit to the place of occurrence, therefore, the defence suggested that he had not followed the procedures required to be complied with for conducting an inspection of place of occurrence during the night hours, therefore, he had not mentioned the time of his visit in the case diary. The witness denied this suggestion but he has stated that in course of his investigation, he had not gone in the village for enquiry and he had not taken any steps to record dying declaration of Deepak Kumar. Deepak Kumar was treated in Maa Janki Hospital but in support thereof, neither bed-head ticket nor admission register or any other certificate was produced. He had not got conducted any test of the seized empty cells of cartridges, he did not find the caliber of the pistol or the gun and he had not found out whether khokha was fired by what capacity of projectile. At the time of occurrence, he was Officer-In-Charge of Runisaidpur Police Station, the Runisaidpur health center is at a distance of 500 yards in east but Sudhir Singh (PW-2) had not lodged any Sanha entry or FIR regarding occurrence prior to his fardbeyan. In paragraph '39', he stated that he had started writing the case diary on November 3, 2018, below the same 04:50 was written which has been cut down and he had put initial thereon whereafter the date is written as November 2, 2018 and then 19:05 was mentioned. This statement of PW-3 would create doubt about his credibility. He has stated that he had reached the place of occurrence on November 2, 2018 at 19:05 Hours but in whose presence, he had inspected the place of occurrence is not known. Cutting in case diary, changing the date and time would make the entry in the diary suspicious. PW-3 stated that Chhotan Singh (PW-1) had not made any statement that near the Murhi Kachri on the ridge a bridge was under construction where along with him Jay Prakash Singh, Prince Singh and Mukesh Singh were present and he had seen that Dinkar Singh @ Sunny and Deepak Kumar S/o Sudhir Singh were eating Murhi Kachri. He had not found any Machan at the Murhi Kachri shop. 

The defence has pointed out to this witness that the page numbers of the case diary are arranged in serials but in his case diary, the pages were not arranged serially. This witness accepted this fact but said that it was due to shortage of diary. On an analysis of the evidence of I.O. (PW-3), the High Court found that he had not conducted the investigation properly. He himself admitted several shortcomings in his investigation. The minimum which he could have done by examining the shopkeeper of Murhi Kachri shop has not been done. There is a huge doubt that he had visited the place of occurrence as his claim that he visited the place of occurrence on November 2, 2018 at 07:05 hours would not inspire confidence of this Court in absence of any seizure list of the articles, seizure list of the empty cartridges, photographs etc. of the place of occurrence. He casually stated about recording of statement of Deepak Kumar. The fact is that no statement of Deepak Kumar is available on record and he himself stated that when he reached the hospital, Deepak Kumar was not in a position to give statement, therefore, he had recorded the statement of his father. In paragraph '18' of his case diary, he mentioned that he recorded the statement of Deepak Kumar but during trial, he admitted that he had not taken certificate of any Medical Officer about the condition of Deepak Kumar to give his statement and the time of recording the statement of Deepak Kumar is not mentioned. On the face of these evidences available on the record, the High Court reached the considered opinion that none of the prosecution witnesses fall in the category of a wholly reliable witness. If no one amongst the prosecution witnesses was wholly reliable witness then the prosecution cannot contend that the evidence of neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable witness may find corroboration from another neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable witness. The Court, in fact, disbelieved that PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3 were the eye witnesses of the occurrence. 

Justice Prasad observed:"53. Before we part with this judgment, it would be necessary to observe as to how the I.O. (PW-3) has conducted the investigation of this case. This Court finds that the absence of any
seizure list of the articles, empty cartridges, photographs etc. as also not bringing the nearby residents of the place of occurrence and the shopkeeper/ staffs into investigation, creates huge doubt that the I.O. (PW-3) had ever visited the place of occurrence. He has casually stated about the recording of the statement of Deepak Kumar but the fact is that no statement of Deepak Kumar is available on the record. Further, he himself has admitted several shortcomings in his investigation."

 

 

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment