“For the purposes of this Protocol: (a) "Trafficking in persons" shall mean the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, for the purpose of exploitation. Exploitation shall include, at a minimum, the exploitation of the prostitution of others or other forms of sexual exploitation, forced labour or services, slavery or practices similar to slavery, servitude or the removal of organs; (b) The consent of a victim of trafficking in persons to the intended exploitation set forth in subparagraph (a) of this article shall be irrelevant where any of the means set forth in subparagraph (a) have been used; (c) The recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of a child for the purpose of exploitation shall be considered "trafficking in persons" even if this does not involve any of the means set forth in subparagraph (a) of this article; (d) "Child" shall mean any person under eighteen years of age.”
-Article 3 of the Protocol to Prevent, Suppress, and Punish Trafficking in Persons especially Women and Children (Palermo Protocol adopted 15th November 2000, entered into force 25th December 2003) which supplements UN Convention against Transnational Organised Crime (adopted 15th November 2000, entered into force 29th September 2003)
Ahead of the next date of hearing on December 14, 2026, in compliance of the 10-page long reminder order dated October 13, 2026 passed by the Supreme Court's Division Bench of Justices J.B.Pardiwala and H.Mahadevan in Prajwala vs. Union of India & Ors.(2026), the Registrar General, Patna High Court has issued the Circular Order No. 03/2026 dated October 15, 2026 on the subject of "Judgment dated 29.05.2026 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Miscellaneous Application No. 530 of 2022 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 56 of 2004 (Prajwala versus Union of India and Others)." The judgement was authored by Justice Pardiwala.
The matter was listed on October 13 for the first time after, the Court had delivered the final judgment, which "dealt with a very delicate, rather a very important and sensitive issue relating to the human trafficking of women and children for commercial sexual exploitation. The Court has provided an extensive ‘Victim Protection Plan’ for strict adherence by all stakeholders in exercise of its plenary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution. It also dealt with, in detail, the prayer as regards the constitution of the Organized Crime Investigation Agency (OCIA). Moreover, from paragraphs 387 to 424, the Court has
provided certain recommendations and suggestions for serious consideration by the Union of India.
The stakeholders involved are:-(i) All Authorities, (ii) State Governments and Departments, (iii) High Courts, (iv) Magistrates, (v) Anti Human Trafficking Units, (vi) Rescue Teams and Leaders, (vii) NGOs and NGO Workers, (viii) Protective Homes, (ix) Social and Case Workers, (x) DLSA and Lawyers, (xi) Police Officers and Police Stations, (xii) Child Welfare Committees, (xiii) Medical and Mental Health Professionals, (xiv) Crime Records Bureau, (xv) Committees Overseeing Protective Homes and (xvi) Anti-Human Trafficking Cell.
The exact ‘Roles and Duties’ assigned to each stakeholder under the ‘Victim Protection Plan’ has been delineated in a tabular format and also indicated the corresponding paragraphs/clauses from our judgment for ease of reference. Additional Solicitor General provided the Court with a status note highlighting what all has been done so far after the judgment was pronounced by the Court. The note specifically dealt with the compliance of the additional directions issued by the Court under paragraph 456 of the main judgment.
It revealed that the four additional directions issued by the Court have not been fully complied with by all the States/UTs, as on date.
The October 13 order reads:"10. We would like to remind the all States/UTs that, (i) notifying “recognized welfare institutions/organisations” in accordance with the explanation to Section 15(6A) ITPA and for the purpose of Section 17A ITPA, (ii) preparation of a State/UT-wide list of social welfare workers eligible to
form a part of the non-official advisory board under Section 13(3)(b) ITPA and the panel maintained by the Magistrate under Section 17(5) ITPA, (iii) designation of a Police Nodal Officer (PNO), and (iv) designation of a Government Nodal Officer (GNO), are absolutely necessary for the ground-level implementation of the ‘Victim Protection Plan’. Therefore, by the next date of hearing, the Union of India
must ensure that the four additional directions as mentioned in paragraph 456 of the main judgment are fully complied with by all States/UTs....12. We are of the view that by the next date of hearing, the Union shall call for the necessary information from all the stakeholders referred to in the note furnished by the learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner, inquiring, in what manner each of the directions have been complied with and what has been done so far for meaningful implementation of the plan which we have provided in the judgment." ITPA refers to Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956.
The senior counsel appearing for the petitioner, an anti-trafficking organisation operating in Hyderabad, Telangana brought to Court's notice two additional aspects that need some urgent attention. First, the Anti-Human Trafficking Unit (ATHUs) should be given status of a police station, in accordance with the directions contained in Paragraph 362 b(iii) at page no.205 of the main judgment dated May 29, 2026, at the earliest. The Court's order reads: "16. In this regard, we direct all the State/UT Governments in their respective Home Departments to give effect to this direction at the earliest by issuing an appropriate notification, in accordance with law. 17. The Union shall also take up this issue at the earliest with all the States/UTs and see to it that appropriate notifications are issued." The petitioner had filed the original petition in 2004.
Secondly, certain guidelines pertaining to the ‘threshold inquiry’ which is to be conducted by the Magistrate under Section 17 of Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956 (ITPA), are necessary. The Court's order reads:"19. In the ‘Victim Protection Plan’, at the stage of production of the rescued victim(s) who are adults (above the age of 18 years) before the Magistrate under Section 17 ITPA, we have incorporated some detailed directions pertaining to the conduction of a ‘threshold inquiry’ to identify voluntary sex workers and the manner in which their release/rehabilitation must be proceeded with. In other words, the need for an additional/parallel judicial determination to identify voluntary sex workers, by the Magistrate, within the framework of Section 17 ITPA, was emphasized by us. The rationale behind the need for such an inquiry is provided under paragraphs 330-356 of our judgment. 20. This judicial determination takes into account various aspects including the consent of the rescued victim and her views on whether she wishes to be placed under long-term safe custody, her statement about the voluntary/nonvoluntary nature of her work, the social worker’s assessment of said voluntariness, whether the victim’s position is influenced by any threats of coercion/undue influence/force, and whether there are any safety concerns placing the victim at real or immediate risk of danger/re-trafficking upon release, amongst others. 21. This threshold inquiry as regards the voluntary nature of the work of the rescued victim is triggered notwithstanding the opinion expressed by the rescued victim that her work is voluntary in nature. In other words, the magistrate must, under all circumstances, conduct this threshold inquiry to determine the further appropriate course of action for the protection, rehabilitation and reintegration of the rescued victim who is an adult.
The order reads: "we request the National Judicial Academy to prepare a comprehensive protocol/guidelines to enable the Magistrates to conduct this inquiry."
The order concluded: "23. There is one another important aspect that we wish to address. Time and again, we have observed that, although this Court painstakingly issues a slew of directions in the form of guidelines or sets up a framework to ensure that the fundamental rights of citizens are safeguarded and enforced in reality, yet once these directions are committed to the paper in the form of a judgment, the matter marks its abrupt end. This Court, more often than not, has no means of knowing whether the frameworks, guidelines or plans are making any measurable differences in people’s lives, or what hindrances stand in the way. The same anxiety grips us here. We have put in place a thorough ‘Victim Protection Plan’ but cannot tangibly ascertain whether it is having the desired impact or faltering in its implementation. To help us gauge this, we would like to hear from both the Petitioner and the Union of India on how they and other involved stakeholders can help us track progress and measure impact. 24. By the next date of hearing, let a fresh status report be placed on record by the Union of India. We would also
like to the petitioner to provide us a fair idea of the progress made by the National Judicial Academy in connection with the preparation of the aforesaid protocol/guidelines for Magistrates. Lastly, we expect both the petitioner and the Union to suggest concrete ways and methods that we can adopt to track the real implementation, progress and impact of the ‘Victim Protection Plan’. 25. Post this matter on 14th December, 2026."
The Supreme Court of India in its 298-page long judgment dated May 29, 2026 passed in Prajwala vs. Union of India & Ors.2026 INSC 609, has, inter alia, issued directions under the "Victim Protection Plan" concerning prosecution and trial of offences relating to trafficking for commercial sexual exploitation.
3. The relevant part of the signed reportable judgment is as under:- “That all the States/UTs notify “recognised welfare institutions or organisations” in accordance with the explanation to Section 15(6A) ITPA. That all States/UTs prepare a State-wide list of social welfare workers, with sufficient representation from all districts, who may be eligible to form a part of the non-official advisory body under Section 13(3)(b) ITPA. That all States/UTs designate the ADGP level police officer heading the Anti-Trafficking Bureau in their respective States/UTs as the Police Nodal Officers for the purpose of performing the functions as delineated by us in the Victim Protection Plan. That all States/UTs shall designate the Secretary, Department of Women and Child Development in their respective States/UTs as the Government Nodal Officers for the purpose of performing the functions as delineated by us in the Victim Protection Plan. It shall be the responsibility of the respondent no. 1 to ensure that the aforesaid directions are duly complied with within a period of three months from the date of this judgment. For the purpose of reporting compliance with the additional directions mentioned in Paragraph No. 456, the Registry shall notify this matter once again sometime in September, 2026. Tackling human trafficking for CSE, with its hidden nature and multifarious forms, is indeed a very daunting task. However, there is recognition from all corners that it is an evil which needs urgent and consistent attention. Various measures have been undertaken by the multitude of stakeholders involved. However, throughout this judgment, we have noted that these measures have not yielded concrete positive results. Thus, there is no hiding away from the fact that much more needs to be done. By formulating a victim protection plan, we believe we have taken a major step in that direction. We hope this effort will have a domino effect, leading to much more sustained and coordinated action from all stakeholders. We are aware that a single plan will not be the answer to all the trials and tribulations victims face. However, our effort here should reflect more than just the formulation of a plan. It should reflect an endeavour to give the victim centre stage and to prioritise their needs. It should reflect an attempt to view victims not as passive beings but as agents in need of empowerment. Lastly, but most importantly, it should reflect a commitment to the victims that this Court will accord them the dignity that was always theirs. We direct the Registry to send one copy of the judgment to: a. All the High Courts; b. Home Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, Union of India c. Principal Secretary, Ministry of Women and Child Development, Union of India." CSE refers to Commercial Sexual Exploitation.
In paragraph 362(g)(iv) of the judgment, the Supreme Court has specifically directed as follows:- "All the High Courts shall ensure the effective implementation of Section 395, BNSS i.e., Order to pay compensation, by all trial courts under their jurisdiction, giving particular regard to subsections 395(1)(b) and 395(3), BNSS respectively."
In view of the direction of the Supreme Court, all the Principal District and Sessions Judges have been hereby directed to ensure effective implementation of Section 395 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023 by all the trial courts under their respective jurisdiction, with particular attention to the requirements contained in Sections 395(l)(b) and 395(3) of the BNSS.
The Circular reads:"The Principal District and Sessions Judges shall accordingly bring the aforesaid direction of the Hon'ble Supreme Court to the notice of all the judicial officers presiding over the trial courts under their respective judgeships and shall ensure that the provisions of Section 395 BNSS are duly considered and implemented in appropriate cases, in accordance with law. The Trial Courts shall ensure that the requirement of passing appropriate orders relating to compensation under Section 395 BNSS is not ·overlooked in cases where the provision is attracted, particularly having regard to the specific emphasis placed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court upon Sections 395(1 )(b) and 395(3) BNSS. The Principal District and Sessions Judges are directed to monitor compliance with the aforesaid direction at the administrative level and to ensure that the direction of the Hon'ble Supreme Court is effectively implemented by the trial courts under their respective jurisdiction."
It adds: "The matter relating to effective implementation of Section 395 BNSS, particularly Sections 395(1)(b) and 395(3) thereof, shall also be specifically included in the agenda of the meeting of District Criminal Injury Compensation Board, and the compliance/ implementation thereof by the trial courts under the respective judgeship shall be reviewed in the said meeting. The aforementioned instructions shall be followed scrupulously henceforth by all concerned and its non-compliance shall be viewed seriously."
The legal infrastructure addressing human trafficking for the purposes of Commercial Sexual Exploitation (CSE) in India comprises of multiple statutory instruments (i) Article 23 of the Constitution of India; (ii) ITPA; (iii) BNS; (iii) The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000; and (v) Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO) respectively. 430. Article 23 of the Constitution prohibits traffic in human beings, begar, and all other similar forms of forced labour.
No comments:
Post a Comment