Showing posts with label Election Commission of India. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Election Commission of India. Show all posts

Monday, February 23, 2026

Patna High Court dismisses PIL on bribery of voters during recent Bihar Legislative Assembly Election

In Anil Kumar vs. The Election Commission of India Through the Chief Election Commissioner & Ors. (2026), Patna High Court's Division Bench of Chief Justice Sangam Kumar Sahoo and Justice Harish Kumar delivered a 4-page long judgement dated February 20, 2026, wherein, it concluded:" So far as violation of Model Code of Conduct is concerned, there is nothing in the petition that the petitioner has approached the Election Commission of India. There is no specific instances have been given that while the Model Code of Conduct was in force, there has been violation and the money has been disbursed to the beneficiaries under the Mukhyamantri Mahila Rojgar Yojna. Therefore, in absence of specific averments taken in the writ petition, we do not feel it proper to entertain this Public Interest Litigation. Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed." The other four respondents were: Chief Electoral Officer, Bihar, State of Bihar Through the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Finance Department, Government of Bihar, Through the Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Bihar and Department implementing the scheme Mukhyamantri Mahila Rojgar Yojna, Through its Principal Secretary, Government of Bihar. The judgement was authored by Chief Justice Sahoo.  

The petitioner alleged that while the Model Code of Conduct during Bihar Legislative Assembly Election, 2025 was in force, at that point of time, some money was transferred in the accounts of the beneficiaries under Mukhyamantri Mahila Rojgar Yojna, which according to the petitioner should not have been done as it amounted to bribing the voters in order to influence them to vote for the ruling parties.

The writ petition was filed with the following prayer(s): “1(i) Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction calling for the complete records relating to the conception, approval, budgetary allocation, advertisements, beneficiary selection criteria and date-wise Direct Benefit Transfer (DBT) details of the scheme titled "Mukhyamantri Mahila Rojgar Yojna", particularly during the subsistence of the Model Code of Conduct.(ii) Direct the Respondent-State of Bihar to file a detailed affidavit disclosing; a.total amount disbursed under the scheme, b.number of beneficiaries, c. date-wise installments released, d. authority permitting continuation of DBT during election period, and e. correspondence exchanged with the Election Commission of India.
(iii) Constitute an Independent High-Level Inquiry Committee, preferably headed by a retired Judge of the Supreme Court of India or the High Court, assisted by financial, administrative and election-law experts, to inquire into: a. the legality, b. intent, c. timing, and d. electoral impact of implementation of the said scheme during the election period.
(iv) Direct that the aforesaid inquiry shall be conducted under the supervision and monitoring of the High Court, with liberty to the Committee to summon records, call officials, examine witnesses, and submit periodical status reports before the High Court.
(v) Direct the Inquiry Committee to specifically examine: (a) whether continuation of the scheme violated the Model Code of Conduct, (b) whether the scheme amounted to inducement or bribery of voters; (c) whether public funds were misused for electoral advantage; (d) whether there was selective or discriminatory non-enforcement of election norms by the Election Commission of India. (vi) Upon completion of the inquiry, direct initiation of appropriate civil, criminal and departmental proceedings against responsible officials and authorities, if any illegality, misconduct or abuse of power is found. (vii) Issue a writ of mandamus directing the Election Commission of India to frame and strictly enforce uniform, binding and transparent guidelines governing Direct Benefit Transfer and welfare scheme disbursement during election periods, applicable uniformly across all States and Union Territories.”

 

Tuesday, June 4, 2024

Writ against rejection of nomination form of candidate from Jehanabad Lok Sabha constituency is "not maintainable": Patna High Court

Relying  on the Supreme Court's pronouncement of law in the case of N. P. Ponnuswami vs Returning officer, Namakkal Constituency, Patna High Court's Single Judge Bench dismissed this writ petition of Abhishek Dangi, the petitioner for the Lok Sabha Eelction-2024 from 36 (Jehanabad Constituency) "as being not maintainable". Dangi was an independent candidate. 

The High Court heard the writ application filed on May 17, 2024 which sought direction upon the concerned Respondent to accept nomination of the petitioner. The petitioner's nomination form was rejected on hyper technical ground on May 15, 2024 by the District Magistrate-cum-Returning Officer, Jehanabad. The Polling date for the said Constituency was on June 1, 2024. The petitioner made detailed representation to the concerned Respondents namely, the Election Commission of India, the District Returning Officer (Lok Sabha Election 2024)-cum District Magistrate, Jehanabad and the  State of Bihar, through the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna on May 16, 2024 but the same was not considered. It was heard on an application seeking urgent listing of the case made by the petitioner before the Joint Registrar. 

The counsel for the Election Commission of India submitted that this writ petition is not maintainable before the High Court in view of Article 329 of the Constitution of India. He submitted that in the similar matter, Supreme Court has held that the word ‘election’ in Article 329 (b) connotes the entire electoral process commencing with the issue of the notification calling the election and culminating in the declaration of result, and that the electoral process once started could not be interfered with at any intermediary stage by Courts. Thus, jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 has been excluded in regard to matters provided for an Article 329 which covers all ‘electoral matters’.

The High Court noted that there is no provision for appeal in the Representation of the People Act, 1951, against order of returning officer accepting or rejecting nomination paper. Nomination and scrutiny, being part of election process. 

It recalled Supreme Court's decision in the case of N. P. Ponnuswami vs Returning officer, Namakkal Constituency & Ors. [1952] S.C.R. The High Court observed that the bar created by Art 329 (b) of the Constitution is applicable to the orders of returning officer accepting or rejecting nomination papers and those orders also will have to be challenged in an election petition and not otherwise at a pre-poll stage. Article 329(b) of the Constitution lays down that "no election to either House of Parliament or to the either House of the Legislatures of a State shall be called in question except by an election petition presented to such authority and in such manner as may be provided for by or under any law made by the appropriate legislature". Similar bar is also created by Section 80 of the Act of 1951 which reads that “no election shall be called in question except by an election petition presented in accordance with the provisions of this part”. Justice Prabhat Kumar Singh's order concluded that "a suit, an appeal or a writ petition challenging the acceptance or rejection of nomination paper in an election to Central or State legislature is not competent." The order was passed on May 21, 2024. 

Notably, on May 31, 2024, the Supreme Court refused to entertain the plea challenging rejection of the nomination from Jehanabad constituency. A vacation bench of Justices Sanjay Karol and Aravind Kumar asked the petitioner to approach a division bench of the Patna High Court with an appeal against the order of the single judge who rejected his petition challenging the rejection of his nomination papers. The court suggested that he can also file an election petition against the High Court order. The lawyer sought permission to withdraw the petition for exhausting the remedy available before the constitutional court. The permission was granted. The matter was dismissed as withdrawn. The website of the High Court indicates that the petitioner has not approached the division bench of the Patna High Court with an appeal against the order of the single judge who rejected his petition challenging the rejection of his nomination form, as yet. It also indicates that no election petition has been filed against the High Court's order so far.


"Counsel seeks permission to withdraw the present petition for exhausting the remedy available before the constitutional court," the bench noted while permitting the counsel to withdraw the plea. The matter was dismissed as withdrawn.

Read more at: https://www.deccanherald.com/elections/india/lok-sabha-elections-2024-sc-refuses-to-entertain-independent-candidates-plea-against-rejection-of-nomination-3046420